Orientation-averaged light scattering by nanoparticle clusters: far-field and near-field benchmarks of numerical cubature methods

Atefeh Fazel-Najafabadi,Baptiste Auguié

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jqsrt.2022.108197

2022-01-25

Abstract:The optical properties of nanoparticles can be substantially affected by their assembly in compact aggregates. This is a common situation notably for nanoparticles synthesised and self-assembled into rigid clusters in colloidal form, where they may be further characterised or used in spectroscopic applications. The theoretical description of such experiments generally requires averaging the optical response over all possible cluster orientations, as they randomly orient themselves over the course of a measurement. This averaging is often done numerically by simulating the optical response for several directions of incidence, using a spherical cubature method. The simulation time increases with the number of directions and can become prohibitive, yet few studies have examined the trade-off between averaging accuracy and computational cost. We benchmark seven commonly-used spherical cubature methods for both far-field and near-field optical responses for a few paradigmatic cluster geometries: dimers of nanospheres and of nanorods, and a helix. The relative error is rigorously evaluated in comparison to analytical results obtained with the superposition T-matrix method. Accurate orientation averaging is especially important for quantities relating to optical activity, the differential response to left and right circularly polarised light, and our example calculations include in particular far-field circular dichroism and near-field local degree of optical chirality.

Optics,Computational Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to effectively perform directional averaging of optical properties in nanoparticle aggregates. Specifically, when nanoparticles exist in the form of rigid aggregates, their Brownian motion in solution will cause the aggregates to be randomly oriented during the measurement process. Therefore, in order to accurately describe the experimental results, theoretically, it is necessary to average the optical responses over all possible aggregate directions. This averaging is usually achieved by numerical methods, that is, simulating the response of light irradiating the aggregates from different incident directions and using spherical cubature methods to approximate the integral. However, as the number of simulation directions increases, the computation time will also increase significantly, which may lead to excessive computation costs. Therefore, the goal of the paper is to benchmark several commonly - used spherical cubature methods and evaluate their performance in far - field and near - field optical response directional averaging, especially for several typical aggregate geometries (such as nanosphere dimers, nanorod dimers and helical structures), in order to find a method to reduce the computation cost while ensuring the accuracy.

The paper pays special attention to quantities related to optical activity, such as circular dichroism (CD) and local degree of optical chirality, because these quantities are very sensitive to the response differences between left - and right - circularly polarized light, and thus may encounter more challenges during the directional averaging process. By comparing with the analytical solutions (obtained by the supermatrix method), the paper strictly evaluates the relative errors of different spherical cubature methods, thereby providing guidance for selecting appropriate numerical methods in practical applications.