Abstract:We exploit the new country-by-country reporting data of multinational corporations, with unparalleled country coverage, to reveal the distributional consequences of profit shifting. We estimate that multinational corporations worldwide shifted over \$850 billion in profits in 2017, primarily to countries with effective tax rates below 10\%. Countries with lower incomes lose a larger share of their total tax revenue due to profit shifting. We further show that a logarithmic function is better suited for capturing the non-linear relationship between profits and tax rates than linear or quadratic functions. Our findings highlight effective tax rates' importance for profit shifting and tax reforms.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper primarily explores the profit-shifting behavior of Multinational Corporations (MNCs) and its impact on global tax fairness. Specifically, the paper attempts to address the following key questions:
1. **Scale of Profit Shifting**: Investigate how much profit MNCs globally have shifted to low-tax countries or tax havens.
2. **Largest Tax Havens**: Identify which countries are the main destinations for profit shifting, particularly those with extremely low effective tax rates.
3. **Most Active MNCs in Profit Shifting**: Identify the home countries of MNCs that are most active in profit shifting.
4. **Countries Losing the Most Due to Profit Shifting**: Assess the proportion of tax revenue lost due to profit shifting in different countries, with a particular focus on low-income countries.
To address these questions, the authors utilized a new dataset—Country-by-Country Reporting (CBCR) data of multinational corporations, which provides unprecedented coverage across countries. They also developed a new method to capture the extreme non-linear relationship between profits and tax rates. This method uses a logarithmic function to model the relationship between profits and effective tax rates, allowing for a more accurate estimation of the extent of profit shifting. Through this method, the paper reveals the following key findings:
- Global MNCs shifted over $850 billion in profits to low-tax countries or tax havens in 2017, resulting in a tax revenue loss of approximately $200 billion to $300 billion for other countries.
- The largest profit-shifting destinations include the Cayman Islands, Luxembourg, Singapore, and other regions with very low effective tax rates.
- MNCs from the United States, Brazil, and Singapore are the most active in profit shifting, while there is no significant evidence of profit-shifting activities by MNCs from South Africa and Malaysia.
- Relative to their total tax revenue, low-income countries lose a higher proportion of tax revenue due to profit shifting, which directly contradicts the 2030 Sustainable Development Agenda's goal of strengthening domestic resource mobilization.
In summary, this paper provides new insights into the scale, distribution, and impact of global profit shifting on different countries through improved methodologies and datasets.