Clifford-deformed Surface Codes

Arpit Dua,Aleksander Kubica,Liang Jiang,Steven T. Flammia,Michael J. Gullans

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PRXQuantum.5.010347

2024-02-28

Abstract:Various realizations of Kitaev's surface code perform surprisingly well for biased Pauli noise. Attracted by these potential gains, we study the performance of Clifford-deformed surface codes (CDSCs) obtained from the surface code by applying single-qubit Clifford operators. We first analyze CDSCs on the $3\times 3$ square lattice and find that, depending on the noise bias, their logical error rates can differ by orders of magnitude. To explain the observed behavior, we introduce the effective distance $d'$, which reduces to the standard distance for unbiased noise. To study CDSC performance in the thermodynamic limit, we focus on random CDSCs. Using the statistical mechanical mapping for quantum codes, we uncover a phase diagram that describes random CDSC families with $50\%$ threshold at infinite bias. In the high-threshold region, we further demonstrate that typical code realizations outperform the thresholds and subthreshold logical error rates, at finite bias, of the best-known translationally invariant codes. We demonstrate the practical relevance of these random CDSC families by constructing a translation-invariant CDSC belonging to a high-performance random CDSC family. We also show that our translation-invariant CDSC outperforms well-known translation-invariant CDSCs such as the XZZX and XY codes.

Quantum Physics,Disordered Systems and Neural Networks,Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Statistical Mechanics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to address the optimization problem of Quantum Error-Correcting (QEC) codes under realistic noise models. Specifically, the authors investigate the performance of Clifford-deformed Surface Codes (CDSCs) under biased Pauli noise.

### Main Issues:
1. **Performance Optimization under Biased Noise**:
- Real-world noise often has biases, such as those encountered in superconducting qubits, ion traps, and spin qubit systems.
- Traditional surface codes (e.g., Kitaev's surface code) perform well under unbiased noise but may degrade under biased noise.
- The authors construct Clifford-deformed Surface Codes (CDSCs) by applying single-qubit Clifford operations to achieve better performance under biased noise.

2. **Performance Analysis of Random CDSCs**:
- Investigate the performance of random CDSCs in the thermodynamic limit, particularly the threshold behavior under infinite biased noise.
- Using statistical mechanics methods, the authors construct a phase diagram describing the performance of random CDSCs under different parameters.
- In the high-threshold region, the authors find that typical random CDSCs can outperform the best-known translationally invariant codes (e.g., XY and XZZX surface codes).

3. **Design of Translationally Invariant CDSCs**:
- Based on the study of random CDSCs, design high-performance translationally invariant CDSCs.
- The authors demonstrate how to extract a specific translationally invariant code from a high-performance family of random CDSCs and verify its superior performance under biased noise.

### Key Methods:
- **Effective Distance and Half-Distance**:
- Introduce the concepts of effective distance \(d'\) and half-distance \(t'\), which better reflect the logical error rate under biased noise.
- **Statistical Mechanics Mapping**:
- Use statistical mechanics methods to relate the performance of QEC codes to phase transitions in classical spin models, thereby analyzing the threshold behavior of CDSCs.
- **Tensor Network Simulations**:
- Perform numerical simulations using tensor network decoders to verify theoretical predictions and optimize the performance of CDSCs.

### Main Conclusions:
- **Performance Advantage of Random CDSCs**:
- Under infinite biased noise, certain random CDSCs can achieve a threshold of 50%, and under moderate biased noise, their performance surpasses the best-known translationally invariant codes.
- **Design of Translationally Invariant CDSCs**:
- Translationally invariant CDSCs extracted from high-performance random CDSC families exhibit excellent performance under biased noise, even surpassing the average performance of the random CDSC family.

### Practical Significance:
- This study provides new insights for the application of quantum error-correcting codes in practical quantum computing, especially for systems with biased noise.
- By optimizing Clifford deformations, it is possible to improve the performance of quantum error-correcting codes while maintaining low overhead, thus advancing the development of fault-tolerant quantum computing.

I hope this summary helps you understand the content of the paper! If you have more questions or need further explanation, please feel free to let me know.