Opinion dynamics involving contrarian and independence behaviors based on the Sznajd model with two-two and three-one agent interactions

Roni Muslim,M Jauhar Kholili,Ahmad R. T. Nugraha

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physd.2022.133379

2022-06-01

Abstract:We investigate the opinion evolution of outflow dynamics based on the Sznajd model on a complete graph involving contrarian and independence behaviors. We consider a group of four spins representing the social agents with the following scenarios: (1) scenario two-two with contrarian agents or independence agents and (2) scenario three-one with contrarian or independence agents. All of them undergo a second-order phase transition according to our simulation. The critical point decreases exponentially as $\lambda$ and $f$ increases, where $\lambda$ and $f$ are contrarian and flexibility factors, respectively. Furthermore, we find that the critical point of scenario three-one is smaller than that of scenario two-two. For the same level of $\lambda$ and $f$, the critical point of the scenario involving independence is smaller than the scenario with contrarian agents. From a sociophysics point of view, we observe that scenario three-one can likely reach a stalemate situation rather than scenario two-two. Surprisingly, the scenarios involving contrarians have a higher probability of achieving a consensus than a scenario involving independence. Our estimates of the critical exponents indicate that the model is still in the same universality class as the mean-field Ising model.

Physics and Society

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the dynamic evolution of social opinions including contrarian and independence behaviors within the framework of the Sznajd model. Specifically, by introducing two new factors - the contrarian factor \(\lambda\) and the flexibility factor \(f\), the author studies the evolution of group opinions in different scenarios and analyzes the influence of these factors on the phase - transition characteristics of the system.

### Research Background and Problem Description

1. **Introduction to the Sznajd Model**
The Sznajd model is a physical model used to simulate the dynamics of social opinions, originally based on the idea of "united we stand, divided we fall". This model is usually used to study how individuals in a group change their opinions under the influence of others.

2. **Introduction of Contrarian and Independence Behaviors**
- **Contrarian Behavior**: It refers to the tendency of an individual to take an opinion opposite to the majority in the group.
- **Independence Behavior**: It refers to an individual who does not follow group norms but acts according to his or her own judgment.

3. **Research Purposes**
The author aims to expand the Sznajd model by considering four different interaction scenarios (two - two interactions and three - one interactions), and combining contrarian and independence behaviors to study how these behaviors affect the phase - transition characteristics of the system. Specifically, it includes:
- Analyzing the critical points of phase transitions in different scenarios.
- Comparing the influence of contrarian and independence behaviors on the order - disorder phase transition of the system.
- Exploring the significance of these behaviors in social physics, especially their roles in forming consensus or deadlock.

### Main Research Contents

1. **Model Construction**
- **Four - Spin Interaction**: Four spins (representing four agents) are defined on a complete graph and divided into two scenarios:
- **Two - Two Scenario**: Two agents persuade the other two agents.
- **Three - One Scenario**: Three agents persuade the fourth agent.

2. **Microscopic Rules**
- For each scenario, microscopic rules including contrarian and independence behaviors are defined respectively. For example, in the two - two scenario:
- **Contrarian Behavior**: Reverse persuasion with probability \(\lambda p\).
- **Independence Behavior**: Act independently with probability \(p\), where the flexibility factor \(f\) determines the probability of an individual changing his or her opinion.

3. **Phase - Transition Analysis**
- By calculating the magnetic susceptibility \(\chi\) and the Binder cumulant \(U\), the critical exponents of the system are estimated and the phase - transition critical point \(p_c\) is determined.
- The results show that as the contrarian factor \(\lambda\) and the flexibility factor \(f\) increase, the critical point \(p_c\) decreases exponentially, and the critical point in the three - one scenario is smaller than that in the two - two scenario.

4. **Explanation in Social Physics**
- In a group with strong contrarian behavior, it is easier to reach a consensus; while in a group with strong independence behavior, it is more likely to fall into a deadlock.
- These results are helpful for understanding the influence of different social behavior patterns on the formation of group opinions, especially in a multicultural context.

### Summary
By introducing contrarian and independence behaviors, this paper expands the classical Sznajd model and deeply explores the influence of these behaviors on the dynamics of social opinions. The research results not only enrich the theoretical basis in the field of social physics but also provide a valuable reference for understanding the formation of group opinions in the real world.