Abstract:We demonstrate the reliability of dynamic causal model of resting‐state magnetoencephalography (MEG) data. Using parametric empirical Bayes (PEB), we confirmed the reliability of posterior probability distributions of inferred dynamic causal modelling (DCM) parameters. The comparison of model evidence associated with the covariance among subject‐specific DCMs' free energies with versus without interclass correlations structure indicated reliability of first‐level DCMs within‐subjects but not between‐subjects. PEB confirmed the expected reciprocal relationship between a conventional definition of 'reliability' and the conditional dependency among inferred model parameters. This study assesses the reliability of resting‐state dynamic causal modelling (DCM) of magnetoencephalography (MEG) under conductance‐based canonical microcircuit models, in terms of both posterior parameter estimates and model evidence. We use resting‐state MEG data from two sessions, acquired 2 weeks apart, from a cohort with high between‐subject variance arising from Alzheimer's disease. Our focus is not on the effect of disease, but on the reliability of the methods (as within‐subject between‐session agreement), which is crucial for future studies of disease progression and drug intervention. To assess the reliability of first‐level DCMs, we compare model evidence associated with the covariance among subject‐specific free energies (i.e., the 'quality' of the models) with versus without interclass correlations. We then used parametric empirical Bayes (PEB) to investigate the differences between the inferred DCM parameter probability distributions at the between subject level. Specifically, we examined the evidence for or against parameter differences (i) within‐subject, within‐session, and between‐epochs; (ii) within‐subject between‐session; and (iii) within‐site between‐subjects, accommodating the conditional dependency among parameter estimates. We show that for data acquired close in time, and under similar circumstances, more than 95% of inferred DCM parameters are unlikely to differ, speaking to mutual predictability over sessions. Using PEB, we show a reciprocal relationship between a conventional definition of 'reliability' and the conditional dependency among inferred model parameters. Our analyses confirm the reliability and reproducibility of the conductance‐based DCMs for resting‐state neurophysiological data. In this respect, the implicit generative modelling is suitable for interventional and longitudinal studies of neurological and psychiatric disorders.

Critical comments on dynamic causal modelling

A strategy of model space search for dynamic causal modeling in task fMRI data exploratory analysis

A fast dynamic causal modeling regression method for fMRI

Spectral Dynamic Causal Modelling: A Didactic Introduction and its Relationship with Functional Connectivity

Dynamic Causal Modeling in Probabilistic Programming Languages

Physiologically informed dynamic causal modeling of fMRI data

Dynamic Causal Models of Time-Varying Connectivity

Thermodynamic integration for dynamic causal models

Characterizing Network Search Algorithms Developed for Dynamic Causal Modeling

Basic Principles of Dynamic Causal Modeling and Its Application in Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging

Regression dynamic causal modeling for resting‐state fMRI

Bayesian fusion and multimodal DCM for EEG and fMRI

Generalized Recurrent Neural Network accommodating Dynamic Causal Modeling for functional MRI analysis

Multiple-shooting adjoint method for whole-brain dynamic causal modeling

[Study of Effective Connectivity Based on Dynamic Causal Modeling in Subtraction Calculation Task].

Neural Changes in the Cortico-Basal Ganglia Network During Online Statistical Sequence Learning: an Fmri Study

Missing data estimation in fMRI dynamic causal modeling

Discrete Dynamic Causal Modeling and Its Relationship with Directed Information

On the intersection between data quality and dynamical modelling of large-scale fMRI signals

Reliability of dynamic causal modelling of resting‐state magnetoencephalography

A Deep Dynamic Causal Learning Model to Study Changes in Dynamic Effective Connectivity during Brain Development