Abstract:Objectives: To assess genetic counselling by non-geneticists and to improve clinical practice. Design: National retrospective review of casenotes. Setting: Antenatal, paediatric, medical, and surgical units. Sample: 1293 genetic events were identified, involving potentially avoidable cases of Down's syndrome, neural tube defect, cystic fibrosis, beta thalassaemia major and late onset medullary carcinoma of the thyroid (multiple endocrine neoplasia). Notes were available for review in 888 (69%) of these cases. Outcomes: Documented counselling, offers of relevant genetic screening and prenatal diagnosis. Results: Clinical audit was frustrated by poor quality hospital records lacking evidence of counselling. Non-geneticist clinicians concentrate on the management of disease, and may overlook the need for counselling and recording data which patients will later need for decisions about reproduction or disease prevention. Counselling, screening and prenatal diagnosis were sometimes impossible because of late booking in pregnancy, or because of delayed diagnosis of an earlier affected child with cystic fibrosis. There are marked regional inequalities of access to genetic services, particularly for minority ethnic groups with increased risks of thalassaemia. Although patients were selected for this enquiry because they had known high risks of genetic disorders, on average less than half were referred to medical geneticists. General recommendations relevant for improvement of care for patients and families with medical genetic needs and those specific for each disorder are given. Conclusions: Assessment of the quality of genetic care becomes increasingly important as genetic counselling spreads beyond the narrow confines of specialist genetic services. Even though the events studied in this enquiry largely occurred between 1991 and 1995, there is little reason to believe that clinicians in general have become markedly better trained in medical genetics. The General Medical Council and Medical Royal Colleges should urgently consider the need for a national policy for improving undergraduate and postgraduate medical, nursing and midwifery education in genetics. Commissioners of clinical services should require that genetic management be at least as well-documented as surgical operations, drug records and informed consent, perhaps by using a nationally agreed pro-forma for prenatal diagnosis. Regular audit of counselling provided by non-geneticists is necessary to confirm that clinical improvements are occurring and standards are being met. The Confidential Enquiry provides data for a systematic approach to clinical governance of genetics in all specialities. This sets the scene for multi-speciality NHS genetic services capable of giving patients greater consistency both in access and in quality.

Towards equity & inclusion: a critical examination of genetic Counselling Education on Intersex Healthcare

Enhancing intersex healthcare: A qualitative study of parental perspectives on the role of genetics

Use of gender‐inclusive language in genetic counseling to optimize patient care

Reflections on diversity, equity, and inclusion in genetic counseling education

Navigating the disclosure landscape: Parents' perspectives on healthcare professionals' role in supporting intersex children and families

Experiences of genetic counselors practicing in multiple languages: Progress and places for improvement

Policy and laboratory practice: How quality control procedures for genetic testing perpetuate biological essentialism and discrimination against transgender, gender diverse, and intersex people

Exploring Genetic Counselors' Experiences with Indigenous Patient Populations

Counseling in a different language: An analysis of experiences and resources in multilingual genetic counseling

Opportunities to optimize patient experience in the in vitro fertilization (IVF) clinic and the role of genetic counselors

Expanding the primary care workforce by integrating genetic counselors in multidisciplinary care teams

Identifying potential LGBTQIA+ competencies for genetic counseling student training

Enduring uncertainties. Medical accounts on caring for young people with variations of sex characteristics

Australian healthcare professionals' perspectives on genetic counseling and genetic diagnosis in vascular anomalies

From intention to action: Assessing need and creating a JEDI toolkit for individuals teaching cancer genetics curriculum

'Do language and culture really matter?': A trans-disciplinary investigation of cultural diversity in genetic counseling in Hong Kong

Becoming agents for genomic change: genetic counsellors' views of patient care and implementation influences when genomics is mainstreamed

Evolving perspectives on genetic discrimination in health insurance among health care providers

Incorporating multiracial and multiethnic experiences into genetic counseling practice and research: A necessary opportunity

Exploring genetic counselors' interest and role in transitional care discussions for pediatric patients with neurodevelopmental conditions

National Confidential Enquiry into counselling for genetic disorders by non-geneticists: general recommendations and specific standards for improving care