Abstract:Diversity plays an important role in various domains, including conservation, whether it describes diversity within a population or diversity over a set of species. While various strategies for measuring among-species diversity have emerged (e.g. Phylogenetic Diversity (PD), Split System Diversity (SSD) and entropy-based methods), extensions to populations are rare. An understudied problem is how to assess the diversity of a collection of populations where each has its own internal diversity. Relying solely on measures that treat each population as a monomorphic lineage (like a species) can be misleading. To address this problem, we present four population-level diversity assessment approaches: Pooling, Averaging, Pairwise Differencing, and Fixing. These approaches can be used to extend any diversity measure that is primarily defined for a group of individuals to a collection of populations. We then apply the approaches to two measures of diversity that have been used in conservation—Heterozygosity (Het) and Split System Diversity (SSD)—across a dataset comprising SNP data for 50 anadromous Atlantic salmon populations. We investigate agreement and disagreement between these measures of diversity when used to identify optimal sets of populations for conservation, on both the observed data, and randomized and simulated datasets. The similarity and differences of the maximum-diversity sets as well as the pairwise correlations among our proposed measures emphasize the need to clearly define what aspects of biodiversity we aim to both measure and optimize, to ensure meaningful and effective conservation decisions. Measuring diversity has several implications including conservation prioritization. However, accurately assessing genetic diversity across multiple populations while considering both within and among population variations is often overlooked. Our study addresses this gap by introducing four novel methods, allowing a better understanding of measuring diversity across populations from different perspectives. We applied these methods to simulated data and data from Atlantic salmon populations. The results sometimes disagree on which populations are most important for conservation, highlighting the need for clear biodiversity goals in conservation decisions. It's important to note that there isn't a single correct answer to the question of how to measure diversity, and the best approach is likely to depend on the conservation priorities and criteria under consideration. By understanding the reason behind these differences, we can make more informed choices to protect our natural world. This research contributes to a broader understanding of diversity and can help guide areas where measuring diversity is important.

Commentary: do we have a consistent terminology for species diversity? We are on the way

A diversity of beta diversities: straightening up a concept gone awry. Part 1. Defining beta diversity as a function of alpha and gamma diversity

Beta-diversity Partitioning: Methods, Applications and Perspectives

Rarefaction, Alpha Diversity, and Statistics

Species Packing and the Latitudinal Gradient in Beta-Diversity

Diversification and diversity partitioning

Alpha, beta, or gamma: where does all the diversity go?

PARTITIONING DIVERSITY INTO INDEPENDENT ALPHA AND BETA COMPONENTS

Use of secondary diversity data to improve diversity estimates at multiple geographic scales

Decoupling Species Richness Variation and Spatial Turnover in Beta Diversity Across a Fragmented Landscape

Publisher Correction: Heterogeneity Within and among Co-Occurring Foundation Species Increases Biodiversity

Functional and phylogenetic β diversities and their link with clustering/overdispersion and uniqueness/redundancy

Synthesis reveals approximately balanced biotic differentiation and homogenization

How to partition diversity

Diversity and its decomposition into variety, balance and disparity

Animal species diversity driven by habitat heterogeneity/diversity: the importance of keystone structures

Measuring genetic diversity across populations

Bridging discrete and continuous formalisms for biodiversity quantification

Fine-grain beta diversity in Palaearctic open vegetation: variability within and between biomes and vegetation types

Understanding diversity–synchrony–stability relationships in multitrophic communities

Measuring diversity. A review and an empirical analysis