Abstract:In many domains, a latent competition among different conventions determines which one will come to dominate. One sees such effects in the success of community jargon, of competing frames in political rhetoric, or of terminology in technical contexts. These effects have become widespread in the online domain, where the data offers the potential to study competition among conventions at a fine-grained level. In analyzing the dynamics of conventions over time, however, even with detailed on-line data, one encounters two significant challenges. First, as conventions evolve, the underlying substance of their meaning tends to change as well; and such substantive changes confound investigations of social effects. Second, the selection of a convention takes place through the complex interactions of individuals within a community, and contention between the users of competing conventions plays a key role in the convention's evolution. Any analysis must take place in the presence of these two issues. In this work we study a setting in which we can cleanly track the competition among conventions. Our analysis is based on the spread of low-level authoring conventions in the eprint arXiv over 24 years: by tracking the spread of macros and other author-defined conventions, we are able to study conventions that vary even as the underlying meaning remains constant. We find that the interaction among co-authors over time plays a crucial role in the selection of them; the distinction between more and less experienced members of the community, and the distinction between conventions with visible versus invisible effects, are both central to the underlying processes. Through our analysis we make predictions at the population level about the ultimate success of different synonymous conventions over time--and at the individual level about the outcome of "fights" between people over convention choices.

The Spontaneous Emergence of Conventions: An Experimental Study of Cultural Evolution

The Dynamics of Social Conventions in LLM populations: Spontaneous Emergence, Collective Biases and Tipping Points

The Dynamics of Norm Change in the Cultural Evolution of Language

Social Conflict and the Evolution of Unequal Conventions

Data-informed modeling of the formation, persistence, and evolution of social norms and conventions

The Emergence of Cultural Attractors: How Dynamic Populations of Learners Achieve Collective Cognitive Alignment

Understanding Norm Change: An Evolutionary Game-Theoretic Approach (Extended Version)

Dynamics of organizational culture: Individual beliefs vs. social conformity

Competition and Selection Among Conventions

An Emergence Approach to Behavior Convention in Agent Group through Propagation of Plans

Spontaneous Emergence of Modularity in a Model of Evolving Individuals and in Real Networks

Reinforcement Communication Learning in Different Social Network Structures

Norm Dynamics: Interdisciplinary Perspectives on Social Norm Emergence, Persistence, and Change

Cultural Evolution as Distributed Computation

Parallels and promising directions in the study of genetic, cultural, and moral evolution

An Evolutionary Framework for Culture: Selectionism versus Communal Exchange

Human Communication Systems Evolve by Cultural Selection

Tipping Points for Norm Change in Human Cultures

Spontaneous emergence of groups and signaling diversity in dynamic networks

Temporal Evolution of Social Innovation

The emergence of division of labor through decentralized social sanctioning