When Environmental Regulations Kill: The Role of Health/Health Analysis

F. Cross

DOI: https://doi.org/10.15779/Z38625X

Abstract:Introduction .................................................... 730 I. The Theories Supporting Health/Health Analysis ......... 732 II. The Association Between Wealth and Health ............. 736 A. The Supporting Evidence ............................. 736 B. The Implications for Regulatory Decisionmaking ..... 741 III. Responses to Criticisms of Health/Health Analysis ....... 743 A. Attacks on Motivation Are Merely Demagogic ....... 743 B. Attacks on Causation Apply an Unrealistic Standard. 745 1. Neither Confounding Variables nor Reverse Causality Explains the Correlation Between W ealth and Health ................................ 745 2. Evidence Supporting Health/Health Analysis is Stronger than Evidence Supporting Much Existing R egulation ......................................... 747 C. Other Methodological Challenges Are Readily A nsw ered ............................................. 752 D. The Need To Consider Regulatory Costs and Their D istribution ........................ .................. 754 1. Measuring the True Societal Cost of Regulation .. 755 2. Accounting for the Regressive Distribution of Economic Costs ..................... ... 762 IV. Application of Health/Health Analysis .................... 764 A. The Legality of Health/Health Analysis ............... 764 1. Occupational Safety and Health Act § 6(b)(5) .... 765 2. Occupational Safety and Health Act § 3(8) ........ 769 3. Clean Air Act § 112 ............................... 770 B. The Procedural Application of Health/Health A nalysis ............................................... 772 1. Determining the Acceptable Regulatory Cost-PerLife-Saved ......................................... 772