Abstract:Fairness measurement is crucial for assessing algorithmic bias in various types of machine learning (ML) models, including ones used for search relevance, recommendation, personalization, talent analytics, and natural language processing. However, the fairness measurement paradigm is currently dominated by fairness metrics that examine disparities in allocation and/or prediction error as univariate key performance indicators (KPIs) for a protected attribute or group. Although important and effective in assessing ML bias in certain contexts such as recidivism, existing metrics don’t work well in many real-world applications of ML characterized by imperfect models applied to an array of instances encompassing a multivariate mixture of protected attributes, that are part of a broader process pipeline. Consequently, the upstream representational harm quantified by existing metrics based on how the model represents protected groups doesn’t necessarily relate to allocational harm in the application of such models in downstream policy/decision contexts. We propose FAIR-Frame, a model-based framework for parsimoniously modeling fairness across multiple protected attributes in regard to the representational and allocational harm associated with the upstream design/development and downstream usage of ML models. We evaluate the efficacy of our proposed framework on two testbeds pertaining to text classification using pretrained language models. The upstream testbeds encompass over fifty thousand documents associated with twenty-eight thousand users, seven protected attributes and five different classification tasks. The downstream testbeds span three policy outcomes and over 5.41 million total observations. Results in comparison with several existing metrics show that the upstream representational harm measures produced by FAIR-Frame and other metrics are significantly different from one another, and that FAIR-Frame’s representational fairness measures have the highest percentage alignment and lowest error with allocational harm observed in downstream applications. Our findings have important implications for various ML contexts, including information retrieval, user modeling, digital platforms, and text classification, where responsible and trustworthy AI are becoming an imperative.

Towards Integrating Fairness Transparently in Industrial Applications

Fairness: from the ethical principle to the practice of Machine Learning development as an ongoing agreement with stakeholders

Improving fairness in machine learning systems: What do industry practitioners need?

Analyzing Fairness of Computer Vision and Natural Language Processing Models

Fairway: SE Principles for Building Fairer Software

FairSense: Long-Term Fairness Analysis of ML-Enabled Systems

Hidden Technical Debts for Fair Machine Learning in Financial Services

Towards Fair Machine Learning Software: Understanding and Addressing Model Bias Through Counterfactual Thinking

Embed systemic equity throughout industrial ecology applications: How to address machine learning unfairness and bias

FairerML: an Extensible Platform for Analysing, Visualising, and Mitigating Biases in Machine Learning [application Notes]

Towards Fair and Explainable AI using a Human-Centered AI Approach

An End-To-End Machine Learning Pipeline That Ensures Fairness Policies

Navigating Fairness: Practitioners' Understanding, Challenges, and Strategies in AI/ML Development

Fairness-aware Configuration of Machine Learning Libraries

FairerML: An Extensible Platform for Analysing, Visualising, and Mitigating Biases in Machine Learning

A Conceptual Framework for Ethical Evaluation of Machine Learning Systems

Should Fairness be a Metric or a Model? A Model-based Framework for Assessing Bias in Machine Learning Pipelines

Towards A Holistic View of Bias in Machine Learning: Bridging Algorithmic Fairness and Imbalanced Learning

Whither Bias Goes, I Will Go: An Integrative, Systematic Review of Algorithmic Bias Mitigation

Towards Fairness Certification in Artificial Intelligence

Fix Fairness, Don't Ruin Accuracy: Performance Aware Fairness Repair using AutoML