Comparative study of optimization method and optimal operation strategy for multi-scenario integrated energy system

Di Wu,Zhonghe Han,Zhijian Liu,Peng Li,Fanfan Ma,Han Zhang,Yunxing Yin,Xinyan Yang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.energy.2020.119311

IF: 9

2021-02-01

Energy

Abstract:Integrated energy system as a welcome multiple-energy system has significant contribution to alleviate the worldwide energy shortage problem. In this paper, the theoretical model of integrated energy system was initially built. Also, a new self-adaption strategy relying on exhaustive search method is proposed for minimal hourly-operation-cost. On the basis, an optimization scheme oriented by minimal annualized system cost is presented for integrated energy system. Based on a case study, the optimal nominal capacity of devices and operation parameters are determined by the optimization scheme, respectively for isolated and connected scenarios with different operation strategies. In isolated scenario, the annualized system cost with self-adaption strategy is the lowest, around $23.60/m2 for commercial building and around $19.39/m2 for office building. In connected scenario, the minimal annualized system cost is $693.3 k (about $19.26/m2). Moreover, the applicability of building-scale and district-scale integrated energy systems in economy is compared. Finally, a collaborative optimization method that combines genetic algorithm and orthogonal experimental design is introduced to determine multiple decision variables for district-scale integrated energy system. The results show that the district-scale integrated energy system determined by collaborative optimization reduces the annualized cost by 0.67% (about $78.8 k), compared by non-collaborative optimization. These findings could provide the reference about integrated energy system optimization and further explore the development potential of multiple-energy system.

energy & fuels,thermodynamics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the following issues:

1. **Optimization Methods**: Optimization methods for the configuration and operation of multi-scenario Integrated Energy Systems (IES). Existing optimization methods mainly focus on the perspective of electrical engineering and fail to fully consider thermodynamic performance, multi-energy complementarity, and energy interconnection between multiple distributed systems.

2. **Operation Strategies**: Developing effective IES operation strategies to improve the system's economic efficiency and energy efficiency. Traditional operation strategies such as Follow Thermal Load (FTL) and Follow Electrical Load (FEL) strategies have issues with energy mismatch, leading to reduced system efficiency.

3. **Applicability Comparison**: Comparing the economic applicability of building-scale and district-scale IES. Existing literature mainly focuses on the optimization of IES but rarely compares the performance and applicability of IES at different scales.

Specifically, the paper proposes the following innovations:

- **Self-Adaptive Strategy (SA)**: Developed a cost-oriented self-adaptive strategy based on an exhaustive search method to achieve the lowest hourly operating cost.
- **Economic Applicability Comparison**: Compared the economic applicability of building-scale and district-scale IES.
- **Collaborative Optimization Method**: Proposed a collaborative optimization method combining Genetic Algorithm (GA) and Orthogonal Experimental Design (OED) for system configuration and operation optimization.

Through these methods, the paper aims to provide a reference for the optimization of IES and further exploration of the development potential of multi-energy systems.