Abstract:While coastal habitat conversion was a primary environmental concern in Asia for the mostly extensive shrimp aquaculture sector in previous decades, the transition towards intensive production is creating new environmental risks, primarily water quality impacts from nutrient-rich effluent. There is a need to compare the performance of conventional and Nature-based Solution (NbS) effluent treatment options given the increasing nutrient loads from more intensive aquaculture and historic loss of ecosystem services from mangrove deforestation. This study evaluates the potential for common and emerging effluent treatment systems to address total nitrogen and total phosphorus effluent from shrimp farms across a spectrum of production intensities. Nutrient waste loading for four stocking density scenarios (7PLm -2 , 20PLm -2 , 75PLm -2 , and 120PLm -2 ) are estimated to compare the treatment efficiency, economic feasibility, spatial requirements, and ecosystem service provision of conventional and NbS effluent treatment systems. We use secondary data to assess effluent treatment systems applicable for shrimp aquaculture in Asia. Findings provide the conceptual framework for comparing the characteristics and tradeoffs of aquaculture effluent treatment systems. Constructed mangrove wetlands are an NbS approach that can meet the intensification needs of aquaculture producers and reduce negative impacts from aquaculture effluent at competitive costs, while also providing ecosystem service co-benefits. Shrimp aquaculture expansion has been a primary driver of mangrove deforestation and degradation globally. Although deforestation rates have slowed considerably in the last two decades, the loss of these critical ecosystems leaves coastal communities vulnerable to climate change risks, like sea level rise and increasing storm surge intensity. Concurrently, the shrimp aquaculture sector has been trending towards more intensive production, resulting in higher production volumes and the concentrated release of nutrient-rich effluent into aquatic ecosystems. These imminent environmental threats from shrimp aquaculture motivate our study focused on common and emerging effluent management approaches. We model four shrimp production intensity scenarios to estimate nutrient waste loads and use those waste loads as inputs to compare seven conventional and Nature-based Solution (NbS) effluent treatment systems. Effluent treatment systems are evaluated based on removal rate efficiencies, equivalent annual costs per kg harvested, spatial footprint requirements, and ecosystem service provision. Our results suggest that constructed mangrove treatment wetlands, a type of NbS approach, are not only an economically viable option for effluent management compared to more conventional approaches, such as settling ponds, but can also provide additional ecosystem services. Our study demonstrates how an NbS approach can be applied to shrimp aquaculture while accommodating commercial production needs and trends towards intensification.

Developing nitrogen bioextraction economic value via off-bottom oyster aquaculture in the northwestern Gulf of Mexico

Comparison of Oyster Aquaculture Methods and Their Potential to Enhance Microbial Nitrogen Removal From Coastal Ecosystems

Ammonia Nitrogen Removal Using Oyster Shell As Alkalinity-Releasing Media in a Biological Nitrification System.

Development and application of an online tool to quantify nitrogen removal associated with harvest of cultivated eastern oysters

Refining the Farm Aquaculture Resource Management Model for Shellfish Nitrogen Removal at the Local Scale

Control of phytoplankton by oysters and the consequent impact on nitrogen cycling in a Subtropical Bay

Opportunities and Challenges for Including Oyster-Mediated Denitrification in Nitrogen Management Plans

Effects of intensive oyster farming on nitrogen speciation in surface sediments from a typical subtropical mariculture bay

Inorganic nitrogen removal in a combined tertiary treatment—marine aquaculture system—I. Removal efficiences

How Do Oysters Remove Nitrogen?

Nutrient reduction by eastern oysters exhibits low variability associated with reproduction, ploidy, and farm location

Oyster Biodeposition Alleviates Sediment Nutrient Overload: A Case Study at Shenzhen Bay, China

A nature-based solutions approach to managing shrimp aquaculture effluent

Seasonal Changes in C, N and P Budgets of Green-Lipped Mussels Perna Viridis and Removal of Nutrients from Fish Farming in Hong Kong

Nitrogen mineralization and immobilization in surface sediments of coastal reclaimed aquaculture ecosystems

Enhancing the Sustainability of Aquaculture Systems Via Nutrient Recycling Using Aquaponics System

Improving Plant Health Through Nutrient Remineralization in Aquaponic Systems

Marine ecological aquaculture: a successful Mediterranean integrated multi-trophic aquaculture case study of a fish, oyster and algae assemblage

Biodeposition of Oysters in an Urbanized Bay Area Alleviates the Black-Malodorous Compounds in Sediments by Altering Microbial Sulfur and Iron Metabolism.

Multi-scale Analysis of Nitrogen Loss Mitigation in the US Corn Belt

Production Characteristics and Optimization of Mitigation Mussel Culture