Publication and collaboration anomalies in academic papers originating from a paper mill: evidence from a Russia-based paper mill

Anna Abalkina

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/leap.1574

2022-03-20

Abstract:This study attempts to detect papers originating from the Russia-based paper mill International publisher LLC. A total of 1009 offers published during 2019-2021 on the <a class="link-external link-http" href="http://123mi.ru" rel="external noopener nofollow">this http URL</a> website were analysed. The study allowed us to identify at least 434 papers that are potentially linked to the paper mill including one preprint, a duplication paper and 15 republications of papers erroneously published in hijacked journals. Evidence of suspicious provenance from the paper mill is provided: matches in title, number of coauthorship slots, year of publication, country of the journal, country of a coauthorship slot and similarities of abstracts. These problematic papers are coauthored by scholars associated with at least 39 countries and submitted both to predatory and reputable journals. This study also demonstrates collaboration anomalies and the phenomenon of suspicious collaboration in questionable papers and examines the predictors of the Russia-based paper mill. The value of coauthorship slots offered by International Publisher LLC in 2019-2021 is estimated at $6.5 million. Since the study analysed a particular paper mill, it is likely that the number of papers with forged authorship is much higher.

Digital Libraries,Information Retrieval

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to identify and analyze academic papers from a certain paper mill in Russia ("International Publisher" LLC) and reveal the characteristics and anomalies of these papers. Specifically, the main problems of the research include:

1. **Identifying papers originating from the paper mill**:
- Through analyzing 1,009 advertisements posted on the 123mi.ru website from 2019 to 2021, the research successfully identified at least 434 papers that may be related to this paper mill. These papers include one pre - print, one repeatedly published paper, and 15 papers that were republished after being wrongly published in hijacked journals.

2. **Providing evidence of suspicious sources**:
- By matching information such as titles, the number of co - authors, the publication year, the country of the journal, the country of the co - authors, and the similarity of abstracts, the research provides evidence of the suspicious sources of these papers.

3. **Demonstrating abnormal cooperation phenomena**:
- The paper explores the phenomenon of suspicious cooperation, that is, in the problematic papers, the cooperation patterns among authors do not conform to the normal academic cooperation rules. For example, the authors may not know each other, have different research interests, come from different universities or professional fields, or even be unfamiliar with the paper topics.

4. **Analyzing predictive factors**:
- The research also examines the activities of Russia - based paper mills and the predictive factors of the fraudulent papers they produce, including but not limited to:
- **Number of co - authors**: On average, each problematic paper has 3.9 co - authors.
- **Cooperation pattern**: There are a large number of interdisciplinary and cross - institutional cooperations, and these cooperations usually lack substantial connections.
- **Country - specific pattern**: For example, the proportion of Chinese scholars as first authors is relatively high, which is related to China's reward mechanism.

5. **Evaluating economic value**:
- It is estimated that from 2019 to 2021, the co - author quotas provided by "International Publisher" LLC are worth approximately $6.5 million.

In summary, this paper aims to reveal the activities of a certain paper mill in Russia, identify the fraudulent papers it produces, and analyze the characteristics and cooperation patterns of these papers, thereby providing methods for the academic community to identify and prevent such unethical behaviors.