ATP Synthase: A Moonlighting Enzyme with Unprecedented Functions

Jean-Nicolas Vigneau,Peyman Fahimi,Maximilian Ebert,Youji Cheng,Connor Tannahill,Paul Muir,Thanh-Tung Nguyen-Dang,Cherif F. Matta
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/D1CC06793A
2022-02-22
Abstract:ATP synthase's intrinsic molecular electrostatic potential (MESP) adds constructively to, and hence reinforces, the chemiosmotic voltage. This ATP synthase voltage represents a new free energy term that appears to have been overlooked. This term is at least roughly equal in order of magnitude and opposite in sign to the energy needed to be dissipated as a Maxwell's demon (Landauer principle).
Biological Physics,Chemical Physics,Biomolecules
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address the role of ATP synthase in bioenergetic conversion and its potential new functions. Specifically, the authors explore how the molecular electrostatic potential (MESP) of ATP synthase affects its contribution to chemiosmosis and propose a new free energy term that may have been overlooked in previous studies. ### Main Research Questions: 1. **The impact of ATP synthase's molecular electrostatic potential (MESP) on chemiosmotic voltage**: - The study found that the MESP of ATP synthase can enhance the chemiosmotic voltage, thereby providing an additional free energy term. - This new free energy term is approximately equal in magnitude but opposite in sign to the energy required for dissipation (such as the energy required by Maxwell's demon). 2. **Non-traditional functions of ATP synthase**: - In addition to its known catalytic function, ATP synthase may also play a role in the kinetic regulation of proton transport. - The authors propose that the structural characteristics of ATP synthase enable it to compensate for the energy that must be dissipated due to the regulation of proton flow. ### Research Background: - **Molecular Electrostatic Potential (MESP)**: Since Jacopo Tomasi introduced MESP research, molecular electrostatics has played an important role in enzyme catalysis and predicting molecular responses to external electric fields. - **Chemiosmotic Theory**: Mitchell's chemiosmotic theory explains the process of energy conversion within cells, but certain free energy terms may have been overlooked in this theory. ### Research Methods: - **High-resolution X-ray diffraction and electron microscopy**: Structures of ATP synthase from different species were obtained. - **Poisson-Boltzmann Equation**: The MESP of ATP synthase was calculated by numerically solving the Poisson-Boltzmann equation. - **Python Code**: An internal Python tool was developed for data processing, protein reorientation, and result analysis. ### Main Findings: - **Contribution of MESP**: The MESP of ATP synthase generates a non-zero potential difference when protons enter and exit the F₀ unit, which is in the same direction as the chemiosmotic voltage, thereby enhancing the overall free energy change. - **Kinetic Regulation**: MESP forms an activation barrier when protons enter the F₀ unit, which may be an important regulatory factor for the rate of proton transport. - **Energy Compensation**: The intrinsic MESP of ATP synthase may help compensate for the energy that must be dissipated due to the regulation of proton flow, thereby maintaining its efficient operation. ### Conclusion: - **ATP synthase is not only a biological catalyst** but also plays an important role in the kinetic regulation of proton transport and free energy changes. - **New Free Energy Terms**: It is suggested to add two new free energy terms to Mitchell's chemiosmotic theory to more comprehensively describe the function of ATP synthase. Through these studies, the authors reveal the multiple roles of ATP synthase in the energy conversion process, providing new perspectives for understanding cellular energy metabolism.