Abstract:The spin-orbit interactions in heavy-metal/ferromagnet heterostructures have attracted considerable attention because they provide an efficient way to manipulate the magnetization with strong current-driven spin-orbit torques (SOTs) via the spin Hall effect in the heavy metal or Rashba effect due to the symmetry breaking at the interface. Theoretical calculations predict no dependence of the SOTs on the out-of-plane angle of magnetization due to spin Hall effect, but Rashba effect induces a nontrivial angular dependence of SOTs. Quantitative measurements with adiabatic harmonic Hall technique have observed the angular dependence in Ta/CoFeB/MgO or $\mathrm{Pt}/\mathrm{Co}/\mathrm{Al}{\mathrm{O}}_{\mathrm{x}}$ with perpendicular magnetic anisotropy. However, this method is complicated because the signal consists of both anomalous and planar Hall contributions. In addition, the fitting of the measurement data is sensitive to the fitting parameters, particularly to the perpendicular anisotropy, in a certain angle region (40--70\ifmmode^\circ\else\textdegree\fi{}). To avoid this uncertainty, we have developed a scheme to quantify the angular dependence of SOTs based on the magneto-optic Kerr effect with field calibration. Without fitting procedures, we precisely determine the SOTs and their angle dependence on the magnetization orientation. We observe a strong angular dependence that is different from the previous experimental observations. Based on this strong dependence, we conclude that a Rashba effect at the same interface, that is responsible for the perpendicular magnetic anisotropy, is the dominant mechanism for the current-driven SOTs in this system.

Quantifying Spin-Orbit Torques in Antiferromagnet/Heavy Metal Heterostructures

Quantifying Angular Dependence of Spin-Orbit Torques in Ta/CoFeB/MgO Trilayers with Perpendicular Magnetic Anisotropy

Determination of the Spin-Orbit Torques in Ferromagnetic–Heavy-Metal Bilayers Using Harmonic Longitudinal Voltage Measurements

Large spin-orbit torque in a-plane $α$-Fe$_{2}$O$_{3}$/Pt bilayers

Leveraging symmetry for an accurate spin-orbit torques characterization in ferrimagnetic insulators

Spin Hall Effects in Metallic Antiferromagnets – Perspectives for Future Spin-Orbitronics

Spin Orbit Torques in Pt-based Heterostructures with Van Der Waals Interface

Theory of In-Plane Current Induced Spin Torque in Metal/ferromagnet Bilayers.

Robust Spin–orbit Torques in Ferromagnetic Multilayers with Weak Bulk Spin Hall Effect

Observation of Nontrivial Spin-Orbit Torque in Single-Layer Ferromagnetic Metals

The Thickness Dependence of the Field-Like Spin–orbit Torque in Heavy Metal/cofeb/mgo Heterostructures

Determination of spin Hall angle in heavy metal/CoFeB-based heterostructures with interfacial spin-orbit fields

Quantitative characterization of the spin orbit torque using harmonic Hall voltage measurements

Anomalous Spin–orbit Torques in Magnetic Single-Layer Films

Alternative harmonic detection approach for quantitative determination of spin and orbital torques

Modulation of Field-Like Spin Orbit Torque in Heavy Metal/ferromagnet Heterostructures

All-electrical Manipulation of Magnetization Dynamics in a Ferromagnet by Antiferromagnets with Anisotropic Spin Hall Effects

Electrical and optical characterizations of spin-orbit torque

Spin orbit effects in CoFeB/MgO hetereostructures with heavy metal underlayers

Spin-orbit torques driven by the interface-generated spin currents

Skew-scattering-induced giant antidamping spin-orbit torques: Collinear and out-of-plane Edelstein effects at two-dimensional material/ferromagnet interfaces