Image-based study of granular column collapse over controlled-roughness surfaces

Shuocheng Yang,Lu Jing,Chung Yee Kwok,Gengchao Yang,Yuri Dumaresq Sobral

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2111.00935

2021-11-01

Abstract:Basal effects have important implications for the high mobility and long runout of granular flows such as rock avalanches and landslides. However, fundamental understanding of the basal effect in granular flows remains challenging due to the complex forms of base roughness and the multiscale nature of flow-bed interactions. Here we experimentally investigate the basal effect in granular column collapse over controlled-roughness bases. Image processing methods are developed to obtain robust measurements of base roughness, runout distance and deposit morphology. A geometric roughness parameter Ra is applied to consider both the size and spatial distribution of base particles, which enables systematic analysis of the basal effect. The results indicate that the runout distance can be characterized as a function of Ra, regardless of the variations in the base particle size and spacing, and the roughness has a major influence on the frontal region of the granular flow, as well as the overall profile of the granular deposit. When Ra is increased beyond a threshold value (Ra > 0.62), flow characteristics show minor changes, which coinsides with a previous phase diagram for the transition between slip and non-slip boundary conditions from steady state granular flow simulations.

Geophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the influence of substrate roughness on the dynamic behavior of granular flow during the collapse process of granular columns on substrates with different roughness. Specifically, the author experimentally studied the collapse process of granular columns on substrates with controlled roughness, aiming to explore how substrate roughness affects the runout distance and deposition morphology of granular flow. The paper pays special attention to the definition of the roughness parameter \(R_a\) and its effectiveness in describing the effect of substrate roughness.

### Main research questions:
1. **Influence of substrate roughness on the runout distance of granular flow**: Study the runout distance after the collapse of granular columns on substrates with different roughness, and explore how roughness affects the propagation distance of granular flow.
2. **Influence of substrate roughness on the deposition morphology**: Analyze the deposition morphology after the collapse of granular columns on substrates with different roughness, especially the morphological changes at the front end of the deposition.
3. **Effectiveness of the roughness parameter \(R_a\)**: Verify whether \(R_a\) can effectively characterize the substrate roughness and whether it can uniformly describe the influence of substrate particles of different sizes and distributions on the granular flow.

### Research methods:
- **Experimental device**: Use an experimental box with a controllable - roughness substrate, and trigger the collapse of the granular column by quickly removing the aluminum door.
- **Image processing**: Use image processing technology to measure substrate roughness, runout distance, and deposition morphology.
- **Roughness parameter \(R_a\)**: Define a geometric roughness parameter \(R_a\), which takes into account the size and spatial distribution of substrate particles, and is used to systematically analyze the influence of substrate roughness.

### Main findings:
- **Relationship between runout distance and roughness**: As \(R_a\) increases, the runout distance of the granular flow monotonically decreases, but when \(R_a\) exceeds a certain threshold (about 0.62), the change in runout distance tends to be flat.
- **Changes in deposition morphology**: Substrate roughness has a significant influence on the deposition morphology at the front end of the granular flow, especially when \(R_a\) is small, the curvature at the front end of the deposition is larger; when \(R_a\) is large, the deposition morphology is closer to a triangle.
- **Effectiveness of the roughness parameter**: \(R_a\) can effectively characterize the substrate roughness and can more accurately reflect the influence of the substrate on the granular flow than the traditional substrate particle diameter \(d_b\).

### Conclusions:
- Substrate roughness has a significant influence on the runout distance and deposition morphology after the collapse of the granular column.
- The roughness parameter \(R_a\) is an effective indicator that can uniformly describe the influence of substrate particles of different sizes and distributions on the granular flow.
- When \(R_a\) exceeds a certain threshold, the influence of substrate roughness on the granular flow tends to be saturated, which is consistent with previous research results.

Through these studies, the author provides new insights for understanding the role of substrate roughness in granular flow dynamics and provides a theoretical basis for future experimental and simulation studies.