Transport Model Comparison Studies of Intermediate-Energy Heavy-Ion Collisions
Hermann Wolter,Maria Colonna,Dan Cozma,Pawel Danielewicz,Che Ming Ko,Rohit Kumar,Akira Ono,ManYee Betty Tsang,Jun Xu,Ying-Xun Zhang,Elena Bratkovskaya,Zhao-Qing Feng,Theodoros Gaitanos,Arnaud Le Fèvre,Natsumi Ikeno,Youngman Kim,Swagata Mallik,Paolo Napolitani,Dmytro Oliinychenko,Tatsuhiko Ogawa,Massimo Papa,Jun Su,Rui Wang,Yong-Jia Wang,Janus Weil,Feng-Shou Zhang,Guo-Qiang Zhang,Zhen Zhang,Joerg Aichelin,Wolfgang Cassing,Lie-Wen Chen,Hui-Gan Cheng,Hannah Elfner,K. Gallmeister,Christoph Hartnack,Shintaro Hashimoto,Sangyong Jeon,Kyungil Kim,Myungkuk Kim,Bao-An Li,Chang-Hwan Lee,Qing-Feng Li,Zhu-Xia Li,Ulrich Mosel,Yasushi Nara,Koji Niita,Akira Ohnishi,Tatsuhiko Sato,Taesoo Song,Agnieszka Sorensen,Ning Wang,Wen-Jie Xie
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2202.06672
2022-02-14
Nuclear Theory
Abstract:Transport models are the main method to obtain physics information from low to relativistic-energy heavy-ion collisions. The Transport Model Evaluation Project (TMEP) has been pursued to test the robustness of transport model predictions in reaching consistent conclusions from the same type of physical model. Calculations under controlled conditions of physical input and set-up were performed with various participating codes. These included both calculations of nuclear matter in a box with periodic boundary conditions, and more realistic calculations of heavy-ion collisions. In this intermediate review, we summarize and discuss the present status of the project. We also provide condensed descriptions of the 26 participating codes, which contributed to some part of the project. These include the major codes in use today. We review the main results of the studies completed so far. They show, that in box calculations the differences between the codes can be well understood and a convergence of the results can be reached. These studies also highlight the systematic differences between the two families of transport codes, known as BUU and QMD type codes. However, when the codes were compared in full heavy-ion collisions using different physical models, as recently for pion production, they still yielded substantially different results. This calls for further comparisons of heavy-ion collisions with controlled models and of box comparisons of important ingredients, like momentum-dependent fields, which are currently underway. We often indicate improved strategies in performing transport simulations and thus provide guidance to code developers. Results of transport simulations of heavy-ion collisions from a given code will have more significance if the code can be validated against benchmark calculations such as the ones summarized in this review.