Violent relaxation in the Hamiltonian mean field model: II. Non-equilibrium phase diagrams

Alessandro Santini,Guido Giachetti,Lapo Casetti

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1742-5468/ac4516

2021-08-27

Abstract:A classical long-range-interacting $N$-particle system relaxes to thermal equilibrium on time scales growing with $N$; in the limit $N\to \infty$ such a relaxation time diverges. However, a completely non-collisional relaxation process, known as violent relaxation, takes place on a much shorter time scale independent of $N$ and brings the system towards a non-thermal quasi-stationary state. A finite system will eventually reach thermal equilibrium, while an infinite system will remain trapped in the quasi-stationary state forever. For times smaller than the relaxation time the distribution function of the system obeys the collisionless Boltzmann equation, also known as the Vlasov equation. The Vlasov dynamics is invariant under time reversal so that it does not "naturally" describe a relaxational dynamics. However, as time grows the dynamics affects smaller and smaller scales in phase space, so that observables not depending upon small-scale details appear as relaxed after a short time. Herewith we present an approximation scheme able to describe violent relaxation in a one-dimensional toy-model, the Hamiltonian Mean Field (HMF). The approach described here generalizes the one proposed in G. Giachetti and L. Casetti, J. Stat. Mech.: Theory Exp. 2019, 043201 (2019), that was limited to "cold" initial conditions, to generic initial conditions, allowing us to to predict non-equilibrium phase diagrams that turn out to be in good agreement with those obtained from the numerical integration of the Vlasov equation.

Statistical Mechanics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem this paper attempts to address is understanding the dynamical behavior of systems with long-range interactions in non-equilibrium states, particularly how these systems rapidly reach quasi-stationary states (QSS) through a process known as "violent relaxation." Specifically, the paper focuses on predicting the non-equilibrium phase diagram and the magnetization of the quasi-stationary state in the Hamiltonian Mean Field (HMF) model based on different initial conditions.

### Background of the Paper
- **Systems with Long-Range Interactions**: These systems are characterized by interaction forces between particles that decay slowly with distance, leading to a relaxation time towards thermal equilibrium that increases with the number of particles \(N\), eventually diverging as \(N \to \infty\).
- **Violent Relaxation**: This is a non-collisional relaxation process that occurs on a much faster timescale than collisional relaxation, quickly bringing the system into a non-thermal quasi-stationary state.
- **Vlasov Equation**: This equation describes the dynamics of collisionless systems and has time-reversal symmetry, theoretically not naturally describing the relaxation process. However, due to small-scale effects in phase space dynamics, macroscopic observables exhibit relaxation behavior over short timescales.

### Objectives of the Paper
- **Develop Approximate Schemes**: The paper proposes a new approximation method to handle the violent relaxation process in the HMF model, applicable to various initial conditions, not just "cold" initial conditions.
- **Predict Non-Equilibrium Phase Diagrams**: Using this method, the authors can predict the non-equilibrium phase diagrams of the system under different initial conditions and compare them with the results from numerically integrating the Vlasov equation.

### Main Contributions
- **Extension of Previous Theories**: Previous work was limited to "cold" initial conditions, whereas the method in this paper can handle arbitrary initial conditions.
- **Detailed Analytical Predictions**: Under low-order approximations, the authors can analytically predict the magnetization of the quasi-stationary state and plot the non-equilibrium phase diagram.
- **Numerical Validation**: The theoretical predictions are validated through numerical simulations of the Vlasov equation.

### Conclusion
- **Consistency of Analytical Predictions with Numerical Results**: In both the cold and hot regions, the theoretical predictions are very consistent with the numerical results.
- **Prediction of Complex Phase Boundaries**: In the warm region, the theory predicts some complex phase boundary features, although these features are not entirely consistent with numerical results in some cases.

Overall, this paper successfully addresses the prediction problem of the violent relaxation process in the HMF model by developing a new approximation method, providing an important theoretical foundation for understanding the non-equilibrium dynamics of systems with long-range interactions.