Abstract:Background: Smart-home technologies, comprising environmental sensors, wearables and video are attracting interest in home healthcare delivery. Development of such technology is usually justified on the basis of the technology's potential to increase the autonomy of people living with long-term conditions. Studies of the ethics of smart-homes raise concerns about privacy, consent, social isolation and equity of access. Few studies have investigated the ethical perspectives of smart-home engineers themselves. By exploring the views of engineering researchers in a large smart-home project, we sought to contribute to dialogue between ethics and the engineering community. Methods: Either face-to-face or using Skype, we conducted in-depth qualitative interviews with 20 early- and mid-career smart-home researchers from a multi-centre smart-home project, who were asked to describe their own experience and to reflect more broadly about ethical considerations that relate to smart-home design. With participants' consent, interviews were audio-recorded, transcribed and analysed using a thematic approach. Results: Two overarching themes emerged: in 'Privacy', researchers indicated that they paid close attention to negative consequences of potential unauthorised information sharing in their current work. However, when discussing broader issues in smart-home design beyond the confines of their immediate project, researchers considered physical privacy to a lesser extent, even though physical privacy may manifest in emotive concerns about being watched or monitored. In 'Choice', researchers indicated they often saw provision of choice to end-users as a solution to ethical dilemmas. While researchers indicated that choices of end-users may need to be restricted for technological reasons, ethical standpoints that restrict choice were usually assumed and embedded in design. Conclusions: The tractability of informational privacy may explain the greater attention that is paid to it. However, concerns about physical privacy may reduce acceptability of smart-home technologies to future end-users. While attention to choice suggests links with privacy, this may misidentify the sources of privacy and risk unjustly burdening end-users with problems that they cannot resolve. Separating considerations of choice and privacy may result in more satisfactory treatment of both. Finally, through our engagement with researchers as participants this study demonstrates the relevance of (bio)ethics as a critical partner to smart-home engineering.

Investigating Personalisation-Privacy Paradox Among Young Irish Consumers: A Case of Smart Speakers

Alexa, Are You Listening?

Personal choices and situated data: Privacy negotiations and the acceptance of household Intelligent Personal Assistants

Privacy Attitudes of Smart Speaker Users

The Personalization-Privacy Paradox On The Adoption Of It-Enabled Personalization: From A Service Value Perspective

"Privacy is the Boring Bit": User Perceptions and Behaviour in the Internet-of-Things

User Preferences of Privacy-Enhancing Attributes of a Smart Speaker

PowerCut and Obfuscator: An Exploration of the Design Space for Privacy-Preserving Interventions for Voice Assistants

Communication privacy management for smart speaker use: Integrating the role of privacy self-efficacy and the multidimensional view

Smart homes, private homes? An empirical study of technology researchers' perceptions of ethical issues in developing smart-home health technologies

Users’ Cognitive and Affective Response to the Risk to Privacy from a Smart Speaker

Beyond the Personalization–Privacy Paradox: Privacy Valuation, Transparency Features, and Service Personalization

Personal Information Disclosure via Voice Assistants: The Personalization–Privacy Paradox

What's up with Privacy?: User Preferences and Privacy Concerns in Intelligent Personal Assistants

Echoes of Privacy: Uncovering the Profiling Practices of Voice Assistants

Exploring the role of overt vs. covert personalization strategy in privacy calculus.

Privacy concerns in the smart home context

Alexa! Examine privacy perception and acceptance of voice-based artificial intelligence among digital natives

White Elephant or Happiness Goodies? The Effect of User Personality on the Perception of Digital Companionship of Smart Speaker

User Perceptions of Smart Home IoT Privacy

In Alexa, We Trust. Or Do We? : An analysis of People's Perception of Privacy Policies