Explainable Machine Learning using Real, Synthetic and Augmented Fire Tests to Predict Fire Resistance and Spalling of RC Columns

M.Z. Naser,V.K. Kodur
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.engstruct.2021.113824
2021-08-23
Abstract:This paper presents the development of systematic machine learning (ML) approach to enable explainable and rapid assessment of fire resistance and fire-induced spalling of reinforced concrete (RC) columns. The developed approach comprises of an ensemble of three novel ML algorithms namely; random forest (RF), extreme gradient boosted trees (ExGBT), and deep learning (DL). These algorithms are trained to account for a wide collection of geometric characteristics and material properties, as well as loading conditions to examine fire performance of normal and high strength RC columns by analyzing a comprehensive database of fire tests comprising of over 494 observations. The developed ensemble is also capable of presenting quantifiable insights to ML predictions; thus, breaking free from the notion of 'blackbox' ML and establishing a solid step towards transparent and explainable ML. Most importantly, this work tackles the scarcity of available fire tests by proposing new techniques to leverage the use of real, synthetic and augmented fire test observations. The developed ML ensemble has been calibrated and validated for standard and design fire exposures and for one, two, three and four-sided fire exposures thus; covering a wide range of practical scenarios present during fire incidents. When fully deployed, the developed ensemble can analyze over 5,000 RC columns in under 60 seconds thus, providing an attractive solution for researchers and practitioners. The presented approach can also be easily extended for evaluating fire resistance and spalling of other structural members and under varying fire scenarios and loading conditions and hence paves the way to modernize the state of this research area and practice.
Machine Learning
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to develop a systematic machine - learning (ML) method to achieve interpretable and rapid assessment of the fire - resistance performance and spalling phenomenon of reinforced concrete (RC) columns in fires. Specifically, the paper mainly addresses the following issues: 1. **Limitations of existing methods**: - Current research and engineering practice mainly rely on manual analysis, empirical methods or complex finite - element (FE) numerical simulations. These methods have problems such as high cost, long time - consumption and the need for specialized software. - Traditional calculation methods lack standardized verification procedures, resulting in limited effectiveness and acceptance. 2. **Data scarcity**: - Fire - test data is scarce, which limits the training and verification effects of models. Therefore, the paper proposes to use real, synthetic and enhanced fire - test data to make up for this deficiency. 3. **The "black - box" problem**: - Traditional machine - learning models are usually regarded as "black - boxes", and it is difficult to explain their prediction results. By introducing interpretable machine - learning (Ex - ML) methods, the paper aims to break this "black - box" characteristic and provide transparent and interpretable prediction results. 4. **Multi - factor complexity**: - The fire - resistance performance and spalling phenomenon of reinforced concrete columns are affected by multiple factors, including geometric features, material properties, loading conditions, etc. By comprehensively considering these factors, the paper has established an ML model capable of handling multi - dimensional inputs. ### Main contributions of the paper - **Developed an integrated ML method**: Combining three algorithms, namely random forest (RF), extreme gradient boosting tree (ExGBT) and deep learning (DL), to form an ensemble learning model. - **Proposed a method to solve data scarcity**: By generating synthetic and enhanced data to expand the training set, the generalization ability of the model is improved. - **Achieved interpretable machine - learning**: It can not only make predictions, but also provide quantitative explanations to help engineers understand the decision - making process of the model. - **Wide applicability**: This method can be applied to RC columns of different types and sizes, and can be extended to other structural members and different fire scenarios. Through these improvements, the paper provides an efficient, transparent and easy - to - use tool for the field of structural fire engineering, promoting the development of performance - based design methods.