Fixation and Creativity in Data Visualization Design: Experiences and Perspectives of Practitioners

Paul Parsons,Prakash Shukla,Chorong Park

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2108.06451

2021-08-14

Abstract:Data visualization design often requires creativity, and research is needed to understand its nature and means for promoting it. The current visualization literature on creativity is not well developed, especially with respect to the experiences of professional data visualization designers. We conducted semi-structured interviews with 15 data visualization practitioners, focusing on a specific aspect of creativity known as design fixation. Fixation occurs when designers adhere blindly or prematurely to a set of ideas that limit creative outcomes. We present practitioners' experiences and perspectives from their own design practice, specifically focusing on their views of (i) the nature of fixation, (ii) factors encouraging fixation, and (iii) factors discouraging fixation. We identify opportunities for future research related to chart recommendations, inspiration, and perspective shifts in data visualization design.

Human-Computer Interaction

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the phenomenon of fixation in data visualization design. Specifically, the author focuses on how data visualization designers are influenced by fixed thinking during the design process, that is, how designers prematurely or blindly adhere to certain concepts, features, representations or solutions, thus limiting the exertion of creativity. Although there has been a lot of research on fixation in other design fields, this phenomenon has not been fully explored in the field of data visualization. Therefore, by interviewing 15 data visualization practitioners, the paper collects their experiences and views on fixation, aiming to gain a deeper understanding of the phenomenon of fixation in data visualization design and its influencing factors, and proposes directions for future research, such as in chart recommendation, inspiration provision and perspective transformation.

### Main research questions:
1. **The nature of fixation**: How do data visualization designers describe their experiences of fixation in actual work?
2. **Factors promoting fixation**: What factors may cause data visualization designers to fall into fixation?
3. **Factors avoiding fixation**: What strategies can help data visualization designers overcome fixation?

### Research methods:
- **Semi - structured interviews**: The author recruited 15 data visualization practitioners through social media, the Slack workspace of DataVis Society, email lists and personal networks.
- **Interview content**: Participants were asked about the creative dilemmas they encountered in projects and how they finally broke through these dilemmas. Then, the researcher introduced the concept of fixation and asked participants about their views on fixation, including factors that may promote or hinder fixation.

### Research findings:
1. **The nature of fixation**:
- All participants reported having experienced fixation at work.
- Fixation has various manifestations, including "getting stuck", "hitting a wall", "finding it hard to let go", "clogging" and so on.
- Some participants described it as over - reliance on initial ideas, while others thought it was the inability to find better solutions.

2. **Factors promoting fixation**:
- **Chart recommendation**: The chart recommendation function in software may cause designers to prematurely adhere to a certain design solution.
- **Ignoring the whole**: Paying too much attention to details and ignoring the overall design.
- **Effort and emotional investment**: Designers invest too much time and energy in a certain solution, making it difficult to give up.
- **Existing practices and habits**: Repeatedly using existing components or following established best practices may lead to fixation.
- **Precedents**: The influence of existing visualization works may cause designers to imitate existing designs.
- **Client influence**: Early suggestions from clients or brand guidelines may cause designers to fall into fixation.

3. **Factors avoiding fixation**:
- **Incubation**: Temporarily putting aside the problem and giving the brain time for unconscious thinking.
- **Experiment and creative exercises**: Trying different visual encodings or conducting creative exercises, such as drawing 10 different solutions.
- **Sources of inspiration**: Looking for inspiration from works in art, nature or other fields.
- **External input**: Discussing with colleagues or seeking feedback from others.
- **Changing perspective**: Thinking about problems from the perspective of a beginner, or observing the design from different physical angles.

### Conclusion:
The paper reveals the phenomenon of fixation in data visualization design and its influencing factors through empirical research, providing directions for future research. In particular, how to avoid fixation while providing chart recommendations and inspiration is an important topic worthy of further exploration.