Abstract:This study presents a comparison of the performance of machine learning (ML) techniques, specifically multi-dimensional gene expression programming (MGEP), tensor basis neural network (TBNN), and also proposes a novel universally interpretable machine learning architecture to model the turbulent scalar flux (UIML-s) to enhance turbulence models for fluid flows at different Prandtl numbers in channels with complex shapes of walls in the channel cross section. In particular, peripheral subchannels of rod bundles are of primary interest. However, the accuracy of mean velocity and scalar distributions predicted by commonly used turbulence models still poses a challenge compared to data extracted from high-fidelity eddy-resolving numerical simulations, particularly for engineering applications involving complex geometry flows. In the present study, by utilizing an explicit algebraic expression for the nonlinear Reynolds-stress term obtained through both the evolutionary MGEP optimization and TBNN, the secondary flow structure has been adequately predicted in the cross-wise mean velocity distributions in the square duct and the rectangular channel with three longitudinal rods. This structure is also observed in the data from the concurrent runs performed by direct numerical simulation (DNS) but is completely absent in the results produced by a baseline Reynolds-averaged Navier–Stokes (RANS) closure, which employs the linear eddy viscosity model for the Reynolds stress tensor. Comparison of MGEP and TBNN has shown their nearly equal performance in a square duct flow; however, MGEP works better for the more complex geometry channel with three rods. Furthermore, based on the velocity field produced by the RANS-MGEP model, the ML modification of the gradient diffusion hypothesis, integrated into the aforementioned novel RANS-ML model called as UIML-s, significantly improves the mean scalar distributions in a flow with three bumps serving as a prototype for the peripheral subchannel of rod bundle. The normalized root mean squared error decreases from 13.5% to 7.6%, bringing the predicted distributions closer to the DNS data, particularly in the near-wall region. Another approach, MGEP-s, also yields the acceptable results, which are nearly identical to those from UIML-s. These findings highlight the potential of using data-driven calibration of turbulence models with nonlinear closures to enhance the predictability for RANS simulations of fluid flows, heat, and mass transfer in channels with complex geometry.

Multiphase turbulence modeling using sparse regression and gene expression programming

Turbulence Model Development based on a Novel Method Combining Gene Expression Programming with an Artificial Neural Network

Sparse identification of multiphase turbulence closures for coupled fluid--particle flows

Data-driven Nonlinear K-L Turbulent Mixing Model Via Gene Expression Programming Method

Data-driven model development for large-eddy simulation of turbulence using gene-expression programing

A coupled framework for symbolic turbulence models from deep-learning

Data-driven turbulence modeling for fluid flow and heat transfer in peripheral subchannels of a rod bundle

Evolutionary Neural Networks for Learning Turbulence Closure Models with Explicit Expressions

Discovering explicit Reynolds-averaged turbulence closures for turbulent separated flows through deep learning-based symbolic regression with non-linear corrections

Machine-learning-assisted Blending of Data-Driven Turbulence Models

Gradient Information and Regularization for Gene Expression Programming to Develop Data-Driven Physics Closure Models

Probabilistic Machine Learning to Improve Generalisation of Data-Driven Turbulence Modelling

Physics-informed Machine Learning Approach for Augmenting Turbulence Models: A Comprehensive Framework

A novel data-driven method for augmenting turbulence modeling for unsteady cavitating flows

Deep Structured Neural Networks for Turbulence Closure Modelling

Toward More General Turbulence Models Via Multicase Computational-Fluid-Dynamics-Driven Training

Interpretable data-driven turbulence modeling for separated flows using symbolic regression with unit constraints

Machine-learnt closure models based on computational space training frameworks for large-eddy simulations in natural convection

Using gene expression programming to discover macroscopic governing equations hidden in the data of molecular simulations

A turbulent eddy-viscosity surrogate modeling framework for Reynolds-averaged Navier-Stokes simulations

Probabilistic data-driven turbulence closure modeling by assimilating statistics