On the existence of marginally trapped tubes in spacetimes with local rotational symmetry

Abbas Sherif

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1140/epjc/s10052-021-09244-z

2021-05-07

Abstract:Let $M$ be a locally rotationally symmetric spacetime with at least one of the rotation or spatial twist being non-zero. It is proved that $M$ cannot admit a non-minimal marginally trapped tube of the form $\chi=X(t)$.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Marginally outer trapped tubes in de Sitter spacetime

Marc Mars,Walter Simon,Roland Steinbauer,Carl Rossdeutscher

2024-07-15

Abstract:We prove two results which are relevant for constructing marginally outer trapped tubes (MOTTs) in de Sitter spacetime. The first one holds more generally, namely for spacetimes satisfying the null convergence condition and containing a timelike conformal Killing vector with a "temporal function". We show that all marginally outer trapped surfaces (MOTSs) in such a spacetime are unstable. This prevents application of standard results on the propagation of stable MOTSs to MOTTs. On the other hand, it was shown recently that, for every sufficiently high genus, there exists a smooth, complete family of CMC surfaces embedded in the round 3-sphere S3. This family connects a Lawson minimal surface with a doubly covered geodesic 2-sphere. We show by a simple scaling argument that this result translates to an existence proof for complete MOTTs with CMC sections in de Sitter spacetime. Moreover, the area of these sections increases strictly monotonically. We compare this result with an area law obtained before for holographic screens.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,Differential Geometry
Toroidal Marginally Outer Trapped Surfaces in Closed Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker Spacetimes: Stability and Isoperimetric Inequalities

Patryk Mach,Naqing Xie

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevd.96.084050

2017-01-01

Abstract:We investigate toroidal marginally outer trapped surfaces (MOTS) and marginally outer trapped tubes (MOTT) in closed Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) geometries. They are constructed by embedding constant mean curvature (CMC) Clifford tori in a FLRWspacetime. This construction is used to assess the quality of certain isoperimetric inequalities, recently proved in axial symmetry. Similarly to spherically symmetric MOTS existing in FLRW spacetimes, the toroidal ones are also unstable.
Symmetry and instability of marginally outer trapped surfaces

Ivan Booth,Graham Cox,Juan Margalef-Bentabol

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1361-6382/ad3dab

2024-03-16

Abstract:We consider an initial data set having a continuous symmetry and a marginally outer trapped surface (MOTS) that is not preserved by this symmetry. We show that such a MOTS is unstable except in an exceptional case. In non-rotating cases we provide a Courant-type lower bound on the number of unstable eigenvalues. These results are then used to prove the instability of a large class of exotic MOTSs that were recently observed in the Schwarzschild spacetime. We also discuss the implications for the apparent horizon in data sets with translational symmetry.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,Differential Geometry
Marginally trapped tubes and dynamical horizons

Ivan Booth,Lionel Brits,Jose A Gonzalez,Chris Van Den Broeck

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/0264-9381/23/2/009

IF: 3.5

2005-12-28

Classical and Quantum Gravity

Abstract:We investigate the generic behaviour of marginally trapped tubes (roughly time-evolved apparent horizons) using simple, spherically symmetric examples of dust and scalar field collapse/accretion onto pre-existing black holes. We find that given appropriate physical conditions the evolution of the marginally trapped tube may be either null, timelike, or spacelike and further that the marginally trapped two-sphere cross-sections may either expand or contract in area. Spacelike expansions occur when the matter falling into a black hole satisfies ρ − P ≤ 1/A, where A is the area of the horizon while ρ and P are respectively the density and pressure of the matter. Timelike evolutions occur when (ρ − P) is greater than this cut-off and so would be expected to be more common for large black holes. Physically they correspond to horizon 'jumps' as extreme conditions force the formation of new horizons outside the old.

astronomy & astrophysics,physics, multidisciplinary, particles & fields,quantum science & technology
On the existence of conformal Killing horizons in LRS spacetimes

Abbas M. Sherif

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10714-024-03197-w

2024-01-03

Abstract:Let $M$ be a locally rotationally symmetric spacetime, and $\xi^a$ a conformal Killing vector for the metric on $M$, lying in the subspace spanned by the unit timelike direction and the preferred spatial direction, and with non-constant components. Under the assumption that the divergence of $\xi^a$ has no critical point in $M$, we obtain the necessary and sufficient condition for $\xi^a$ to generate a conformal Killing horizon. It is shown that $\xi^a$ generates a conformal Killing horizon if and only if either of the components (which coincide on the horizon) is constant along its orbits. That is, a conformal Killing horizon can be realized as the set of critical points of the variation of the component(s) of the conformal Killing vector along its orbits. Using this result, a simple mechanism is provided by which to determine if an arbitrary vector in an expanding LRS spacetime is a conformal Killing vector that generates a conformal Killing horizon. In specializing the case for which $\xi^a$ is a special conformal Killing vector, provided that the gradient of the divergence of $\xi^a$ is non-null, it is shown that LRS spacetimes cannot admit a special conformal Killing vector field, thereby ruling out conformal Killing horizons generated by such vector fields.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology
An Alexandrov theorem in Minkowski spacetime

Oussama Hijazi,Sebastian Montiel,Simon Raulot

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1909.04900

2019-09-11

Abstract:In this paper, we generalize a theorem {à} la Alexandrov of Wang, Wang and Zhang [WWZ] for closed codimension-two spacelike submanifolds in the Minkowski spacetime for an adapted CMC condition .

Differential Geometry
Marginally trapped surfaces in spaces of oriented geodesics

Nikos Georgiou,Brendan Guilfoyle

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.geomphys.2014.03.012

IF: 1.38

2014-08-01

Journal of Geometry and Physics

Abstract:We investigate the geometric properties of marginally trapped surfaces (surfaces which have null mean curvature vector) in the spaces of oriented geodesics of Euclidean 3-space and hyperbolic 3-space, endowed with their canonical neutral Kaehler structures. We prove that every rank one surface in these four manifolds is marginally trapped. In the Euclidean case we show that Lagrangian rotationally symmetric sections are marginally trapped and construct an explicit family of marginally trapped Lagrangian tori. In the hyperbolic case we explore the relationship between marginally trapped and Weingarten surfaces, and construct examples of marginally trapped surfaces with various properties.

mathematics,physics, mathematical
GLOBAL STABILITY OF SPACETIMES WITH SUPERSYMMETRIC COMPACTIFICATIONS

Lars Andersson,Pieter Blue,Zoe Wyatt,Shing-Tung Yau

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2140/apde.2023.16.2079

2023-01-01

Analysis & PDE

Abstract:This paper proves the stability, with respect to the evolution determined by the vacuum Einstein equations, of the Cartesian product of high-dimensional Minkowski space with a compact, Ricci-flat Riemannian manifold that admits a spin structure and a nonzero parallel spinor. Such a product includes the example of Calabi-Yau and other special holonomy compactifications, which play a central role in supergravity and string theory. The stability proved in this paper provides a counter example to an instability argument by Penrose.
Weakly trapped surfaces in asymptotically de Sitter spacetimes

Piotr T. Chruściel,Gregory J. Galloway,Eric Ling

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1361-6382/aac30d

2018-05-10

Abstract:It is a standard fact that trapped or marginally trapped surfaces are not visible from conformal infinity, under the usual set of conditions on matter fields and the conformal completion, provided that the cosmological constant is non-positive. In this note we show that the situation is more delicate in the presence of a positive cosmological constant: we present examples of visible marginally trapped surfaces, and we provide a set of natural conditions which guarantee non-visibility.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology
On complete trapped submanifolds in globally hyperbolic spacetimes

Alma L. Albujer,Jónatan Herrera,Rafael M. Rubio

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1751-8121/ace864

2024-02-07

Abstract:The aim of this manuscript is to obtain rigidity and non-existence results for parabolic spacelike submanifolds with causal mean curvature vector field in orthogonally splitted spacetimes, and in particular, in globally hyperbolic spacetimes. We also obtain results regarding the geometry of submanifolds by ensuring, under some mild hypothesis, the non-existence of local minima or maxima of certain distinguished function. Furthermore, in this last case the submanifold does not need to be parabolic or even complete.

Differential Geometry,Mathematical Physics
On the genericity of singularities in spacetimes with weakly trapped submanifolds

Victor Luis Espinoza,Ivan Pontual Costa e Silva

2024-06-14

Abstract:We investigate suitable, physically motivated conditions on spacetimes containing certain submanifolds - the so-called {weakly trapped submanifolds} - that ensure, in a set of neighboring metrics with respect to a convenient topology, that the phenomenon of nonspacelike geodesic incompleteness (i.e., the existence of singularities) is generic in a precise technical sense. We obtain two sets of results. First, we use strong Whitney topologies on spaces of Lorentzian metrics on a manifold $M$, in the spirit of Lerner, and obtain that while the set of singular Lorentzian metrics around a fiducial one possessing a weakly trapped submanifold $\Sigma$ is not really generic, it is nevertheless prevalent in a sense we define, and thus still quite ``large'' in this sense. We prove versions of that result both for the case when $\Sigma$ has codimension 2, and for the case of higher codimension. The second set of results explore a similar question, but now for initial data sets containing MOTS. For this case, we use certain well-known infinite dimensional, Hilbert manifold structures on the space of initial data and use abstract functional-analytic methods based on the work of Biliotti, Javaloyes, and Piccione to obtain a true genericity of null geodesic incompleteness around suitable initial data sets containing MOTS.

Differential Geometry,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology
Singular space-times with bounded algebraic curvature scalars

Renan B. Magalhães,Gabriel P. Ribeiro,Haroldo C.D. Lima Junior,Gonzalo J. Olmo,Luís C.B. Crispino

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1475-7516/2024/05/114

2024-05-29

Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics

Abstract:We show that the absence of unbounded algebraic curvature invariants constructed from polynomials of the Riemann tensor cannot guarantee the absence of strong singularities. As a consequence, it is not sufficient to rely solely on the analysis of such scalars to assess the regularity of a given space-time. This conclusion follows from the analysis of incomplete geodesics within the internal region of asymmetric wormholes supported by scalar matter which arise in two distinct metric-affine gravity theories. These wormholes have bounded algebraic curvature scalars everywhere, which highlights that their finiteness does not prevent the emergence of pathologies (singularities) in the geodesic structure of space-time. By analyzing the tidal forces in the internal wormhole region, we find that the angular components are unbounded along incomplete radial time-like geodesics. The strength of the singularity is determined by the evolution of Jacobi fields along such geodesics, finding that it is of strong type, as volume elements are torn apart as the singularity is approached. Lastly, and for completeness, we consider the wormhole of the quadratic Palatini theory and present an analysis of the tidal forces in the entire space-time.

astronomy & astrophysics,physics, particles & fields
Marginally outer trapped tori in black hole spacetimes

Kam To Billy Sievers,Liam Newhook,Sarah Muth,Ivan Booth,Robie A. Hennigar,Hari K. Kunduri

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevd.109.124023

IF: 5.407

2024-06-11

Physical Review D

Abstract:During a binary black hole merger, multiple intermediary marginally outer trapped tubes connect the initial pair of apparent horizons with the final (single) apparent horizon. The marginally outer trapped surfaces (MOTSs) that foliate these tubes can have complicated geometries as well as nonspherical topologies. In particular, toroidal MOTSs form inside both of the original black holes during the early stages of a head-on merger that starts from time-symmetric initial data [1]. We show that toroidal MOTSs also form in the maximal analytic extension of the Schwarzschild spacetime as Kruskal time advances from the T=0 moment of time symmetry. As for the merger simulations, they cross the Einstein-Rosen bridge and are tightly sandwiched between the apparent horizons in the two asymptotic regions at early times. This strongly suggests that their formation is a consequence of the initial conditions rather than merger physics. Finally, we consider MOTSs of spherical topology in the Kruskal-Szekeres slicing and study their properties. All of these are contained within the apparent horizon but some do not enclose the wormhole. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.109.124023 © 2024 American Physical Society

astronomy & astrophysics,physics, particles & fields
Superrotations at Spacelike Infinity

Adrien Fiorucci,Javier Matulich,Romain Ruzziconi

2024-04-03

Abstract:We propose a consistent set of boundary conditions for gravity in asymptotically flat spacetime at spacelike infinity, which yields an enhancement of the Bondi-Metzner-Sachs group with smooth superrotations and new subleading symmetries. These boundary conditions are obtained by allowing fluctuations of the boundary structure which are responsible for divergences in the symplectic form, and a renormalisation procedure is required to obtain finite canonical generators. The latter are then made integrable by incorporating boundary terms into the symplectic structure, which naturally derive from a linearised spin-two boundary field on a curved background with positive cosmological constant. Finally, we show that the canonical generators form a non-linear algebra under the Poisson bracket and verify the consistency of this structure with the Jacobi identity.

High Energy Physics - Theory
Existence of closed geodesics on certain non-compact Riemannian manifolds

Akashdeep Dey

2023-08-01

Abstract:Let $M$ be a complete Riemannian manifold. Suppose $M$ contains a bounded, concave, open set $U$ with $C^0$ boundary. Moreover, we assume that $M\setminus U$ is connected and either the relative homotopy set $\pi_1(M,M\setminus U)=0$ or the image of the homomorphism $\pi_1(M\setminus U)\rightarrow \pi_1(M)$ (induced by the inclusion $M\setminus U\hookrightarrow M$) is a finite index subgroup or a normal subgroup of $\pi_1(M)$ or the relative homology group $H_1(M,M\setminus U)\neq 0$. Then there exists a non-trivial closed geodesic on $M$. This partially proves a conjecture of Chambers, Liokumovich, Nabutovsky and Rotman.

Differential Geometry
The Timelike Tube Theorem in Curved Spacetime

Alexander Strohmaier,Edward Witten

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00220-024-05009-3

IF: 2.361

2024-06-20

Communications in Mathematical Physics

Abstract:The timelike tube theorem asserts that in quantum field theory without gravity, the algebra of observables in an open set is the same as the corresponding algebra of observables in its "timelike envelope" , which is an open set that is in general larger. The theorem was originally proved in the 1960's by Borchers and Araki for quantum fields in Minkowski space. Here we sketch the proof of a version of the theorem for quantum fields in a general real analytic spacetime. Details have appeared elsewhere.

physics, mathematical
On Smoothness of Timelike Maximal Cylinders in Three-Dimensional Vacuum Spacetimes

Luc Nguyen,Gang Tian

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/0264-9381/30/16/165010

IF: 3.5

2013-01-01

Classical and Quantum Gravity

Abstract:We show that timelike maximal cylinders in R1+2 always develop singularities in finite time and that, infinitesimally at a generic singularity, their time slices are evolved by a rigid motion or a self-similar motion. We also prove a mild generalization in other backgrounds.

On the existence of marginally trapped tubes in spacetimes with local rotational symmetry

Marginally outer trapped tubes in de Sitter spacetime

Toroidal Marginally Outer Trapped Surfaces in Closed Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker Spacetimes: Stability and Isoperimetric Inequalities

Symmetry and instability of marginally outer trapped surfaces

Marginally trapped tubes and dynamical horizons

On the existence of conformal Killing horizons in LRS spacetimes

An Alexandrov theorem in Minkowski spacetime

Marginally trapped surfaces in spaces of oriented geodesics

GLOBAL STABILITY OF SPACETIMES WITH SUPERSYMMETRIC COMPACTIFICATIONS

Weakly trapped surfaces in asymptotically de Sitter spacetimes

On complete trapped submanifolds in globally hyperbolic spacetimes

On the genericity of singularities in spacetimes with weakly trapped submanifolds

Singular space-times with bounded algebraic curvature scalars

Marginally outer trapped tori in black hole spacetimes

Superrotations at Spacelike Infinity

Existence of closed geodesics on certain non-compact Riemannian manifolds

The Timelike Tube Theorem in Curved Spacetime

On Smoothness of Timelike Maximal Cylinders in Three-Dimensional Vacuum Spacetimes