Abstract:Objective: There is longstanding interest in using EEG measurements to inform transcranial Electrical Stimulation (tES) but adoption is lacking because users need a simple and adaptable recipe. The conventional approach is to use anatomical head-models for both source localization (the EEG inverse problem) and current flow modeling (the tES forward model), but this approach is computationally demanding, requires an anatomical MRI, and strict assumptions about the target brain regions. We evaluate techniques whereby tES dose is derived from EEG without the need for an anatomical head model, target assumptions, difficult case-by-case conjecture, or many stimulation electrodes. Approach: We developed a simple two-step approach to EEG-guided tES that based on the topography of the EEG: (1) selects locations to be used for stimulation; (2) determines current applied to each electrode. Each step is performed based solely on the EEG with no need for head models or source localization. Cortical dipoles represent idealized brain targets. EEG-guided tES strategies are verified using a finite element method simulation of the EEG generated by a dipole, oriented either tangential or radial to the scalp surface, and then simulating the tES-generated electric field produced by each model-free technique. These model-free approaches are compared to a 'gold standard' numerically optimized dose of tES that assumes perfect understanding of the dipole location and head anatomy. We vary the number of electrodes from a few to over three hundred, with focality or intensity as optimization criterion. Main results: Model-free approaches evaluated include (1) voltage-to-voltage, (2) voltage-to-current; (3) Laplacian; and two Ad-Hoc techniques (4) dipole sink-to-sink; and (5) sink to concentric. Our results demonstrate that simple ad hoc approaches can achieve reasonable targeting for the case of a cortical dipole, remarkably with only 2-8 electrodes and no need for a model of the head. Significance: Our approach is verified directly only for a theoretically localized source, but may be potentially applied to an arbitrary EEG topography. For its simplicity and linearity, our recipe for model-free EEG guided tES lends itself to broad adoption and can be applied to static (tDCS), time-variant (e.g., tACS, tRNS, tPCS), or closed-loop tES.

Shamo: A tool for electromagnetic modeling, simulation and sensitivity analysis of the head

Head models of healthy and depressed adults for simulating the electric fields of non-invasive electric brain stimulation

Finite Element Modeling of Human Head from MRI

Realistic head modeling of electromagnetic brain activity: An integrated Brainstorm pipeline from MRI data to the FEM solution

Non-contact Parametric Estimation and Localization of Human Head for Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS)

Human head 3 D finite element model for transcranial electric stimulation

Validation of Numerical Simulation for Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation with Spherical Phantom.

Computational simulation of transcranial current stimulation: Based on an image-derived head model

A simple method for EEG guided transcranial electrical stimulation without models

3D modeling of the total electric field induced by transcranial magnetic stimulation using the boundary element method

Deep Learning-Based Development of Personalized Human Head Model With Non-Uniform Conductivity for Brain Stimulation

Investigating the electric field distribution in the human brain model induced by a high focality transcranial magnetic coil

Effect of intermittent hypoxic training on hypoxia tolerance based on brain functional connectivity.

An adaptive H-refinement method for the boundary element fast multipole method for quasi-static electromagnetic modeling

Influence of segmentation accuracy in structural MR head scans on electric field computation for TMS and tES

The New York Head—A precise standardized volume conductor model for EEG source localization and tES targeting

Bayesian experimental design for head imaging by electrical impedance tomography

A Full-wave Solution of Deep Sources in the Lossy Human Head to Accurate Electroencephalography and Magnetoencephalography

Optimizing intracranial electric field distribution through temperature-driven scalp conductivity adjustments in transcranial electrical stimulation

Improved Dipole Source Localization from Simultaneous MEG-EEG Data by Combining a Global Optimization Algorithm with a Local Parameter Search: A Brain Phantom Study

SHARM: Segmented Head Anatomical Reference Models