Abstract:In recent work of Hazan and Krauthgamer (SICOMP 2011), it was shown that finding an $\eps$-approximate Nash equilibrium with near-optimal value in a two-player game is as hard as finding a hidden clique of size $O(\log n)$ in the random graph $G(n,1/2)$. This raises the question of whether a similar intractability holds for approximate Nash equilibrium without such constraints. We give evidence that the constraint of near-optimal value makes the problem distinctly harder: a simple algorithm finds an optimal 1/2-approximate equilibrium, while finding strictly better than 1/2-approximate equilibria is as hard as the Hidden Clique problem. This is in contrast to the unconstrained problem where more sophisticated algorithms, achieving better approximations, are known. Unlike general Nash equilibrium, which is in PPAD, optimal (maximum value) Nash equilibrium is NP-hard. We proceed to show that optimal Nash equilibrium is just one of several known NP-hard problems related to Nash equilibrium, all of which have approximate variants which are as hard as finding a planted clique. In particular, we show this for approximate variants of the following problems: finding a Nash equilibrium with value greater than $\eta$ (for any $\eta>0$, even when the best Nash equilibrium has value $1-\eta$), finding a second Nash equilibrium, and finding a Nash equilibrium with small support. Finally, we consider the complexity of approximate pure Bayes Nash equilibria in two-player games. Here we show that for general Bayesian games the problem is NP-hard. For the special case where the distribution over types is uniform, we give a quasi-polynomial time algorithm matched by a hardness result based on the Hidden Clique problem.

On the Approximate Purification of Mixed Strategies in Games with Infinite Action Sets

Approximate Nash Equilibria via Sampling

Inapproximability of Nash Equilibrium

Strong Nash equilibria and mixed strategies

Inapproximability of NP-Complete Variants of Nash Equilibrium

Evolution of mixed strategies in monotone games

Computing Approximate Nash Equilibria for Integer Programming Games

On the diffuseness of incomplete information game

Pure Strategy Best Responses to Mixed Strategies in Repeated Games

The equilibrium properties of obvious strategy profiles in games with many players

Computing Nash Equilibria: Approximation and Smoothed Complexity

Simultaneous incremental support adjustment and metagame solving: An equilibrium-finding framework for continuous-action games

Best Approximate Solution for Generalized Nash Games and Quasi-optimization Problems

PPAD-Complete Pure Approximate Nash Equilibria in Lipschitz Games

On the Approximation of Nash Equilibria in Sparse Win-Lose Multi-player Games

Nash's Existence Theorem for Non-compact Strategy Sets

The Search-and-Mix Paradigm in Approximate Nash Equilibrium Algorithms

Numerical approximations of the value of zero-sum stochastic differential impulse controls game in finite horizon

On Tightness of Tsaknakis-Spirakis Descent Methods for Approximate Nash Equilibria

An Approximation Theorem and Generic Uniqueness of Weakly Pareto-Nash Equilibrium for Multiobjective Population Games

Nash, Conley, and Computation: Impossibility and Incompleteness in Game Dynamics