Abstract:Low inflation was once a welcome to both policy makers and the public. However, Japan's experience during the 1990's changed the consensus view on price of economists and central banks around the world. Facing deflation and zero interest bound at the same time, Bank of Japan had difficulty in conducting effective monetary policy. It made Japan's stagnation unusually prolonged. Too low inflation which annoys central banks today is translated into the "Phillips curve puzzle". In the US and Japan, in the course of recovery from the Great Recession after the 2008 global financial crisis, the unemployment rate had steadily declined to the level which was commonly regarded as lower than the natural rate or NAIRU. And yet, inflation stayed low. In this paper, we consider a minimal model of dual labor market to explore what kind of change in the economy makes the Phillips curve flat. The level of bargaining power of workers, the elasticity of the supply of labor to wage in the secondary market, and the composition of the workforce are the main factors in explaining the flattening of the Phillips curve. We argue that the changes we consider in the model, in fact, has plausibly made the Phillips curve flat in recent years.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address the question of why the Phillips Curve has flattened in recent years. Specifically, the author explores the reasons why, during the economic recovery in Japan and the United States following the 2008 global financial crisis, inflation rates remained low despite unemployment rates falling to levels typically considered below the natural rate of unemployment (NAIRU).
### Background
- **Low Inflation**: Once considered a boon by policymakers and the public, Japan's experience in the 1990s changed economists' and central banks' views on prices.
- **Japan's Issue**: After the financial bubble burst in the early 1990s, Japan fell into deflation. The Bank of Japan (BOJ) lowered nominal interest rates to zero, but faced with deflation and the zero lower bound, the BOJ struggled to implement effective monetary policy, leading to an unusually prolonged economic stagnation in Japan.
- **Phillips Curve Puzzle**: In the United States and Japan, during the economic recovery following the 2008 global financial crisis, unemployment rates steadily declined to levels below the natural rate of unemployment, but inflation rates remained very low (0.5% in Japan, 1.5% in the United States).
### Research Methodology
- **Two-Tier Labor Market Model**: The author proposes a minimal two-tier labor market model to explore the economic changes that have flattened the Phillips Curve.
- **Key Factors**:
- The bargaining power level of workers
- Wage elasticity in the secondary labor market
- Changes in labor force structure
### Main Findings
- **Bargaining Power**: The bargaining power of primary workers has weakened.
- **Secondary Labor Supply**: The supply of secondary labor has increased.
- **Wage Elasticity**: Wage elasticity in the secondary labor market has increased.
- **Productivity**: The relative productivity of secondary workers has improved.
### Conclusion
- **Structural Changes**: Structural changes in Japan's labor market over the past 30 years, such as the increase in the proportion of secondary workers and the weakening of primary workers' bargaining power, have collectively led to the flattening of the Phillips Curve.
- **Policy Recommendations**: To achieve inflation targets, structural reforms in the labor market are necessary to reverse or mitigate the impact of these changes.
### Policy Implications
- **Structural Reforms**: To achieve inflation targets, policymakers need to undertake structural reforms in the labor market, including enhancing the bargaining power of primary workers and reducing the supply of secondary labor.
- **Flexible Employment Market**: Past reforms aimed at making the employment market more flexible and the de-unionization of labor unions should be reconsidered to alleviate the upward wage rigidity for all employed labor, especially secondary workers.
Through these analyses, the author provides an explanation for the flattening of the Phillips Curve in recent years and offers specific recommendations for policymakers.