Abstract:We compare the normal-state resistivities $\rho$ and the critical temperatures $T_c$ for superconducting $d_{x^2-y^2}$ pairing due to antiferromagnetic (AF) spin fluctuation exchange in the context of the two phenomenological dynamical spin susceptibility models, recently proposed by Millis, Monien, and Pines (MMP) and Monthoux and Pines (MP) and, respectively, by Radtke, Ullah, Levin, and Norman (RULN), for the cuprate high-$T_c$ materials. Assuming comparable electronic bandwidths and resistiviies in both models, we show that the RULN model gives a much lower d-wave $T_c$ ($\lsim20$K) than the MMP model (with $T_c\sim100$K). We demonstrate that these profound differences in the $T_c$'s arise from fundamental differences in the spectral weight distributions of the two model susceptibilities and are {\it{not}} primarily caused by differences in the calculational techniques employed by MP and RULN. The MMP model, claimed to fit NMR data in YBCO, exhibits substantial amounts of spin fluctuation spectral weight up to an imposed cut-off of 400meV, whereas, in the RULN model, claimed to fit YBCO neutron scattering data, the weight is narrowly peaked and effectively cut-off by 100meV. Further neutron scattering experiments, to explore the spectral weight distribution at all wavevectors over a sufficiently large excitation energy range, will thus be of crucial importance to resolve the question whether AF spin fluctuation exchange provides a viable mechanism to account for high-$T_c$ superconductivity. The large high-frequency boson spectral weight, needed to generate both a high d-wave $T_c$ and a low normal-state resistivity, also implies large values, of order unity, for the Migdal smallness parameter, thus casting serious doubt on the validity of the very

Decisive proofs of the $s_\pm \to s_{++}$ transition in the temperature dependence of the magnetic penetration depth

Magnetic impurities in the two-band $s_\pm$-wave superconductors

Kondo Signatures of a Quantum Magnetic Impurity in Topological Superconductors

Interband coupling and transport interband scattering in $s_{\pm}$ superconductors

Superfluid density of the $\pm$s-wave state for the iron-based superconductors

Magnetic impurities in a strongly coupled superconductor

Diamagnetic property and optical absorption in conventional superconductors with magnetic impurities

Strong-coupling approach to temperature dependence of competing orders of superconductivity: Possible time-reversal symmetry breaking and nontrivial topology

Multiband superconductivity in V 3 Si determined from studying the response to controlled disorder

Temperature-dependent Spectral Function of a Kondo Impurity in an S -Wave Superconductor

Broadened quantum critical ground state in a disordered superconducting thin film

Robustness of s-wave pairing symmetry in iron-based superconductors and its implications to fundamentals on magnetically-driven high temperature superconductivity

On Magnetic Impurities in Gapless Fermi Systems

Interplay Between Superconductivity and Itinerant Magnetism in Underdoped Ba1−xKxFe2As2 (x = 0.2) Probed by the Response to Controlled Point-Like Disorder

Magnetism And Disorder Effects On Muon Spin Rotation Measurements Of The Magnetic Penetration Depth In Iron-Arsenic Superconductors

Transition from Sign-Reversed to Sign-Preserved Cooper-Pairing Symmetry in Sulfur-Doped Iron Selenide Superconductors.

Superconductivity mediated by quantum critical antiferromagnetic fluctuations: The rise and fall of hot spots

Contrasting Dynamic Spin Susceptibility Models and their Relation to High Temperature Superconductivity

Temperature-Dependent Transformation of the Magnetic Excitation Spectrum on Approaching Superconductivity Infe1+y−x(ni/cu)x<…

Finite-temperature phase transitions in $S=1/2$ three-dimensional Heisenberg magnets from high-temperature series expansions

Single Impurity Effects in Multiband Superconductors with Different Sign Order Parameters