A dynamic network model of societal complexity and resilience inspired by Tainter's theory of collapse

Florian Schunck,Marc Wiedermann,Jobst Heitzig,Jonathan F. Donges

2023-12-21

Abstract:In recent years, several global events have severely disrupted economies and social structures, undermining confidence in the resilience of modern societies. While empirical evidence on the dynamics and drivers of past societal collapse is mounting, a process-based understanding of these dynamics is still in its infancy. Here we aim to identify and illustrate the underlying drivers of such societal instability or even collapse. The inspiration for this work is Joseph Tainter's theory of the "collapse of complex societies", which postulates that the complexity of societies increases as they solve problems, leading to diminishing returns on complexity investments, and ultimately to collapse. In this work we have abstracted this theory into a low-dimensional and stylised model of two classes of networked agents, hereafter referred to as "laborers" and "administrators". We numerically modeled the dynamics of societal complexity, measured as the fraction of "administrators", which is assumed to affect the productivity of connected energy-producing "laborers". We show that collapse becomes increasingly likely as the complexity of the model society continuously increases in response to external stresses that emulate Tainter's abstract notion of problems that societies must solve. We also provide an analytical approximation of the system's dominant dynamics, which matches well with the numerical experiments, and use it to study the influence on network link density, social mobility and productivity. Our work advances the understanding of social-ecological collapse and illustrates its potentially direct link to an ever-increasing societal complexity in response to external shocks or stresses via a self-reinforcing feedback.

Physics and Society,Populations and Evolution

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper aims to explore the relationship between social complexity and resilience, and attempts to understand the fundamental drivers that lead to social instability and even collapse. The research is inspired by Joseph Tainter's "Theory of the Collapse of Complex Societies," which posits that societies increase their complexity by solving problems, but the returns on this investment in complexity gradually diminish, potentially leading to societal collapse.

To achieve this goal, the authors constructed a dynamic network model to simulate a networked society composed of two types of agents ("workers" and "managers"). In this model, the proportion of "managers" represents a measure of social complexity and is assumed to affect the ability of connected "workers" to produce energy. "Workers" are responsible for producing the energy needed to sustain the society.

The model demonstrates through numerical simulations that as social complexity continues to increase in response to external pressures, the likelihood of societal collapse also increases. The authors also provide an analytical approximation of the system's dominant dynamics, which aligns well with the numerical experiment results, and use this approximation to study the impact of network link density, social mobility, and productivity.

In summary, the goal of the paper is to identify and illustrate the fundamental factors that lead to social instability or collapse, and to show how these factors are directly linked to the ever-increasing social complexity through self-reinforcing feedback mechanisms, particularly in the face of external shocks or pressures, using a low-dimensional and simplified model.