Economic controls co-design of hybrid microgrids with tidal/PV generation and lithium ion/flow battery storage

Jonathan Cohen,Michael Kane,Alexia Marriott,Franklin Ollivierre III,Krissy Govertsen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2102.05197
2021-02-10
Abstract:Islanded microgrids powered by renewable energy require costly energy storage systems due to the uncontrollable generators. Energy storage needs are amplified when load and generation are misaligned on hourly, monthly, or seasonal timescales. Diversification of both loads and generation can smooth out such mismatches. The ideal type of battery to smooth out remaining generation deficits will depend on the duration(s) that energy is stored. This study presents a controls co-design approach to design an islanded microgrid, showing the benefit of hybridizing tidal and solar generation and hybridizing lithium-ion and flow battery energy storage. The optimization of the microgrid's levelized cost of energy is initially studied in grid-search slices to understand convexity and smoothness, then a particle swarm optimization is proposed and used to study the sensitivity of the hybrid system configuration to variations in component costs. The study highlights the benefits of controls co-design, the need to model premature battery failure, and the importance of using battery cost models that are applicable across orders of magnitude variations in energy storage durations. The results indicate that such a hybrid microgrid would currently produce energy at five times the cost of diesel generation, but flow battery innovations could bring this closer to only twice the cost while using 100% renewable energy.
Systems and Control
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to design a cost - effective hybrid micro - grid system that can utilize two renewable energy sources, tidal energy and solar energy, and combine two energy storage technologies, lithium - ion batteries and flow batteries, to meet the electricity demands of island communities. Specifically, the research aims to reduce the levelized cost of energy (LCOE) of the system by optimizing the design of the micro - grid, while taking into account the early failure of battery life and the applicability of different battery cost models to changes in energy storage duration. ### Research Background and Objectives With the integration of renewable energy in the power grid, its volatility and unpredictability bring many challenges. Especially in island micro - grids, since it is difficult to match the supply and demand of renewable energy, an efficient energy storage system (ESS) is required to balance the supply - demand difference and ensure the stability and reliability of energy supply. However, a single energy storage technology can hardly meet the requirements of long life, high power density and high energy density simultaneously, which provides an opportunity for the development of hybrid ESS. This paper aims to optimize the design of the hybrid micro - grid by proposing a control co - design method that can optimize both the system scale and the controller parameters. The research focuses on the following points in particular: 1. **Hybrid Renewable Energy**: Combine tidal energy and solar energy to improve the diversity and stability of energy supply. 2. **Hybrid Energy Storage Technologies**: Use lithium - ion batteries and flow batteries to take advantage of their respective strengths. For example, lithium - ion batteries are suitable for fast response and high - power applications, while flow batteries are suitable for long - term energy storage. 3. **Economic Analysis**: Evaluate the economic feasibility of the system by optimizing the LCOE of the micro - grid. 4. **Battery Life Model**: Consider the service life and cycle life of the battery to avoid early failure caused by overuse. ### Main Contributions 1. **First - time Research**: For the first time, the economic advantages of combining solar photovoltaic (PV) with tidal energy and lithium - ion batteries with flow batteries are studied. 2. **Control Algorithm**: A filter - based control algorithm is proposed to determine the charge - discharge strategy for each battery type. 3. **Battery Life Modeling**: Different models are used for lithium - ion batteries and flow batteries respectively, not only using the maximum service life but also considering the actual cycle life. 4. **Flexible Simulation Environment**: Provide a flexible simulation environment for future research. ### Conclusions The research shows that although the current LCOE of this hybrid micro - grid is five times that of diesel - fired power generation, technological innovation in flow batteries is expected to reduce its cost to about twice that of diesel - fired power generation while achieving 100% renewable energy use. This research provides important references and guidance for the future design and optimization of hybrid micro - grids.