Mining the Mind: Linear Discriminant Analysis of MEG source reconstruction time series supports dynamic changes in deep brain regions during meditation sessions

D. Calvetti,B. Johnson,A. Pascarella,F. Pitolli,E. Somersalo,B. Vantaggi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10548-021-00874-w

2021-01-29

Abstract:Meditation practices have been claimed to have a positive effect on the regulation of mood and emotion for quite some time by practitioners, and in recent times there has been a sustained effort to provide a more precise description of the changes induced by meditation on human brain. Longitudinal studies have reported morphological changes in cortical thickness and volume in selected brain regions due to meditation practice, which is interpreted as evidence for effectiveness of it beyond the subjective self reporting. Evidence based on real time monitoring of meditating brain by functional imaging modalities such as MEG or EEG remains a challenge. In this article we consider MEG data collected during meditation sessions of experienced Buddhist monks practicing focused attention (Samatha) and open monitoring (Vipassana) meditation, contrasted by resting state with eyes closed. The MEG data is first mapped to time series of brain activity averaged over brain regions corresponding to a standard Destrieux brain atlas, and further by bootstrapping and spectral analysis to data matrices representing a random sample of power spectral densities over bandwidths corresponding to $\alpha$, $\beta$, $\gamma$, and $\theta$ bands in the spectral range. We demonstrate using linear discriminant analysis (LDA) that the samples corresponding to different meditative or resting states contain enough fingerprints of the brain state to allow a separation between different states, and we identify the brain regions that appear to contribute to the separation. Our findings suggest that cingulate cortex, insular cortex and some of the internal structures, most notably accumbens, caudate and putamen nuclei, thalamus and amygdalae stand out as separating regions, which seems to correlate well with earlier findings based on longitudinal studies.

Neurons and Cognition,Numerical Analysis

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem this paper attempts to address is the real-time monitoring of changes in brain activity patterns during meditation using functional imaging techniques (such as MEG) to provide quantitative evidence of the effects of meditation on the brain. Specifically, the researchers aim to identify, through Linear Discriminant Analysis (LDA), which brain regions show the most significant changes in activity during different meditation states and resting states, thereby verifying whether meditation can indeed cause changes in brain structure and function.

### Main Research Questions:
1. **Identify Changes in Brain Activity**: Using MEG data, identify which brain regions show the most significant changes in activity during different meditation states (focused meditation and open monitoring meditation) and resting states.
2. **Verify the Effects of Meditation**: Through quantitative analysis, verify whether meditation can indeed cause changes in brain activity patterns, thereby supporting the positive effects of meditation on brain function and structure.
3. **Compare Consistency Across Individuals and Time Points**: Analyze changes in brain activity during meditation across different individuals and at different time points for the same individual, to verify the effectiveness and consistency of the method.

### Research Background:
- **Potential Benefits of Meditation**: Meditation is widely believed to promote physical and mental health, reduce stress and anxiety, and improve attention and cognitive performance.
- **Limitations of Existing Research**: Many studies on the effects of meditation rely on self-reports, which are subject to bias and difficult to quantify and assess for clinical potential.
- **Importance of Functional Brain Imaging**: Functional brain imaging techniques (such as MEG, EEG, fMRI) can monitor brain activity in real-time, providing more objective evidence.

### Research Methods:
- **Data Collection**: MEG data were collected from experienced Buddhist monks, including three states: eyes-closed resting state, focused meditation (Samatha), and open monitoring meditation (Vipassana).
- **Data Processing**: Independent Component Analysis was used to remove cardiac and eye movement artifacts, and the Iterative Alternating Sequence (IAS) hierarchical Bayesian algorithm was used to solve the MEG inverse problem, generating activity maps of brain regions.
- **Spectral Analysis**: Power spectral density analysis was performed on different frequency bands (θ, α, β, γ) to generate sample matrices.
- **Linear Discriminant Analysis (LDA)**: LDA was used to analyze the sample matrices in different states, identifying brain regions that best distinguish between different states.

### Key Findings:
- **Significant Changes in Brain Regions**: The study found that the cingulate cortex, insular cortex, and some internal structures (such as the nucleus accumbens, caudate nucleus, putamen, thalamus, and amygdala) showed the most significant changes in activity during different meditation states and resting states.
- **Consistency with Previous Research**: These findings are consistent with results from longitudinal studies, further supporting the positive effects of meditation on brain structure and function.

### Conclusion:
This study successfully identified the brain regions with the most significant changes in activity during different meditation states using MEG data and LDA analysis, providing quantitative evidence for the positive effects of meditation on brain function and structure. This not only verifies the potential benefits of meditation but also offers new perspectives for further research on the mechanisms of meditation.