To VaR, or Not to VaR, That is the Question

Victor Olkhov

2024-04-27

Abstract:We consider economic obstacles that limit the reliability and accuracy of value-at-risk (VaR). Investors who manage large market transactions should take into account the impact of the randomness of large trade volumes on predictions of price probability and VaR assessments. We introduce market-based probabilities of price and return that depend on the randomness of market trade values and volumes. Contrary to them, the conventional frequency-based price probability describes the case of constant trade volumes. We derive the dependence of market-based price volatility on the volatilities and correlation of trade values and volumes. In the coming years, that will limit the accuracy of price probability predictions to Gaussian approximations, and even the forecasts of market-based price volatility will be inaccurate and highly uncertain.

General Economics,General Finance,Portfolio Management,Pricing of Securities,Risk Management

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the application of Value-at-Risk (VaR) in financial risk management and the challenges it faces. Specifically, the paper attempts to address the following key issues:

1. **The Concept and Historical Development of VaR**: The paper first reviews the historical background and development process of VaR as a risk measurement tool. VaR, as a method for assessing the potential loss of a financial asset portfolio, was first proposed by JP Morgan in the late 1960s and has since been widely applied in financial markets.

2. **Selection and Prediction of Price Probability**: The paper delves into how to select and predict the probability distribution of prices when calculating VaR. The traditional approach is to define price probability based on trading frequency, but the author points out that this method may not be the best way to describe the randomness of market prices.

3. **Impact of Market Transactions on Price Fluctuations**: The author introduces a new method to consider the impact of the randomness of market transaction value and quantity on price probability. By analyzing the statistical characteristics of market transactions, the paper reveals how the fluctuations in market transaction value and quantity and their correlation affect price fluctuations.

4. **Economic Barriers Limiting Prediction Accuracy**: The paper further discusses the economic barriers faced when predicting price probability, particularly regarding the issue of predicting price fluctuations. The author believes that in the coming years, due to the lack of necessary theoretical and technical support, predicting price probability will be limited to Gaussian approximations, which significantly limits the effectiveness and reliability of VaR.

5. **Conclusion and Outlook**: Finally, the paper summarizes the main issues currently faced by VaR and points out that only by developing new economic theories and technical means can the accuracy of predicting price and return fluctuations be significantly improved. Until these advancements are achieved, there remains a high degree of uncertainty in predicting the probability of prices and returns.

In summary, the paper aims to improve the risk assessment method of VaR by introducing a new perspective on market transactions and points out the limitations of current methods, providing important directions for future financial risk management.