A Work-Centered Approach for Cyber-Physical-Social System Design: Applications in Aerospace Industrial Inspection

Garrick Cabour,Élise Ledoux,Samuel Bassetto
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2101.05385
2021-01-14
Abstract:Industrial inspection automation in aerospace presents numerous challenges due to the dynamic, information-rich and regulated aspects of the domain. To diagnose the condition of an aircraft component, expert inspectors rely on a significant amount of procedural and tacit knowledge (know-how). As systems capabilities do not match high level human cognitive functions, the role of humans in future automated work systems will remain important. A Cyber-Physical-Social System (CPSS) is a suitable solution that envisions humans and agents in a joint activity to enhance cognitive/computational capabilities and produce better outcomes. This paper investigates how a work-centred approach can support and guide the engineering process of a CPSS with an industrial use case. We present a robust methodology that combines fieldwork inquiries and model-based engineering to elicit and formalize rich mental models into exploitable design patterns. Our results exhibit how inspectors process and apply knowledge to diagnose the component`s condition, how they deal with the institution`s rules and operational constraints (norms, safety policies, standard operating procedures). We suggest how these patterns can be incorporated in software modules or can conceptualize Human-Agent Teaming requirements. We argue that this framework can corroborate the right fit between a system`s technical and ecological validity (system fit with operating context) that enhances data reliability, productivity-related factors and system acceptance by end-users.
Human-Computer Interaction
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on the following aspects: 1. **Challenges in industrial inspection automation**: In the aerospace field, industrial inspection automation faces many challenges, including dynamic working environments, abundant information, and strict rules and regulations. These factors make it difficult for existing automation systems to fully replace the knowledge and judgment of human experts. 2. **Limitations of human cognition and machine intelligence**: Although machine - learning algorithms have made significant progress, current systems are still unable to handle a large number of variables, fuzzy rules, and soft data (i.e., information that is difficult for machines to read) in actual working scenarios. At the same time, human cognitive abilities are also limited, and the human error rate in visual inspections can reach 20% - 30%. 3. **Deficiencies in the human - machine collaboration (HAT) design method**: Currently, there is a lack of effective methods to capture and translate field survey data and transform it into specific design patterns to support the functional specifications and ecological validity assessment of CPSS (Cyber - Physical - Social System). 4. **How to transform field survey data into design inputs**: The paper proposes a work - centered approach. By systematically analyzing industrial inspection work, understanding the nature of the work and the challenges it faces, and formalizing operational knowledge to guide technology development, system implementation, and the conceptualization of human - machine collaboration requirements. Specifically, the research questions of the paper are as follows: - **RQ1**: How do inspectors check and determine the status of parts on - site? What are the factors that affect their cognition (decision - making and perception processes) and actions? What are the interdependencies between these factors and other socio - technical system participants? - **RQ2**: What types of field survey data should be passed on to software and automation engineers? How can the collected field survey data be formalized into actionable design patterns aligned with CPSS conceptualization and preliminary design? By solving these problems, the paper aims to provide a methodology for the development of future intelligent systems, ensuring that the systems can meet operational requirements and handle all variables in the actual problem space.