Energy funnelling within multichromophore architectures monitored with subnanometre resolution

Shuiyan Cao,Anna Rosławska,Benjamin Doppagne,Michelangelo Romeo,Michel Féron,Frédéric Chérioux,Hervé Bulou,Fabrice Scheurer,Guillaume Schull

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41557-021-00697-z

2021-06-04

Abstract:In natural and artificial light-harvesting complexes (LHC) the resonant energy transfer (RET) between chromophores enables an efficient and directional transport of solar energy between collection and reaction centers. The detailed mechanisms involved in this energy funneling are intensely debated, essentially because they rely on a succession of individual RET steps that can hardly be addressed separately. Here, we developed a scanning tunnelling microscopy-induced luminescence (STML) approach allowing visualizing, addressing and manipulating energy funneling within multi-chromophoric structures with sub-molecular precision. We first rationalize the efficiency of the RET process at the level of chromophore dimers. We then use highly resolved fluorescence microscopy (HRFM) maps to follow energy transfer paths along an artificial trimer of descending excitonic energies which reveals a cascaded RET from high- to low-energy gap molecules. Mimicking strategies developed by photosynthetic systems, this experiment demonstrates that intermediate gap molecules can be used as efficient ancillary units to convey energy between distant donor and acceptor chromophores. Eventually, we demonstrate that the RET between donors and acceptors is enhanced by the insertion of passive molecules acting as non-covalent RET bridges. This mechanism, that occurs in experiments performed in inhomogeneous media and which plays a decisive role in fastening RET in photosynthetic systems, is reported at the level of individual chromophores with atomic-scale resolution. As it relies on organic chromophores as elementary components, our approach constitutes a powerful model to address fundamental physical processes at play in natural LHC.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand and optimize the energy transfer mechanism in multi - chromophore structures, especially to achieve efficient and directional energy transfer through Resonance Energy Transfer (RET). Specifically, the researchers developed a Scanning Tunneling Microscope - induced Luminescence (STM - induced luminescence, STML) method to visualize, manipulate and monitor the energy funneling effect in multi - chromophore systems with sub - nanometer - level resolution.

### Main problems and goals

1. **Understand the energy transfer mechanism in natural and artificial light - harvesting complexes (LHCs)**:
- In natural and artificial light - harvesting complexes, Resonance Energy Transfer (RET) between chromophores enables solar energy to be efficiently transferred between the collection center and the reaction center. However, the specific mechanism of this energy funneling effect is not fully understood yet, because they depend on a series of individual RET steps that are difficult to study separately.

2. **Develop high - resolution techniques to monitor energy transfer paths**:
- The researchers developed the STML method, which can observe and manipulate the energy transfer process in multi - chromophore structures with sub - molecular precision. This method can analyze in detail the RET efficiency between individual chromophore pairs and reveal the energy transfer paths.

3. **Verify the role of intermediate - gap molecules**:
- By constructing trimers composed of large - gap molecules (such as PdPc), medium - gap molecules (such as ZnPc) and small - gap molecules (such as H₂Pc), the researchers showed that intermediate - gap molecules can act as efficient auxiliary units to promote energy transfer between distant donors and acceptors.

4. **Explore the influence of passive molecules on energy transfer**:
- The study also explored the role of inserting passive molecules (such as PdPc) as non - covalent RET bridges. These molecules enhanced the energy transfer between donors and acceptors in the experiment, similar to the phenomenon in photosynthetic systems.

### Formula representation

- **Resonance Energy Transfer (RET) efficiency**:
\[
\text{RET eff} = \frac{I_A}{I_D + I_A}
\]
where \( I_D \) and \( I_A \) are the emission intensities of the donor and the acceptor respectively.

- **Spectral overlap integral**:
\[
J(\lambda) = \int F_D(\lambda) \epsilon_A(\lambda) d\lambda
\]
where \( F_D(\lambda) \) is the fluorescence spectrum of the donor and \(\epsilon_A(\lambda)\) is the absorption spectrum of the acceptor.

Through these studies, the authors not only revealed the microscopic mechanism of energy transfer in multi - chromophore systems, but also provided important theoretical and technical support for the design of efficient artificial light - harvesting systems.