Comparison of two bundles for reducing surgical site infection in colorectal surgery: multicentre cohort study
Miriam Flores-Yelamos,Aina Gomila-Grange,Josep M Badia,Alexander Almendral,Ana Vázquez,David Parés,Marta Pascual,Enric Limón,Miquel Pujol,Montserrat Juvany,members of the VINCat Colorectal Surveillance Team,Domenico Fraccalvieri,Ana Abad-Torrent,Alejandro Solís-Peña,Mireia Puig-Asensio,Lucrecia López,Marta Piriz,Mercè Hernández,Dolors Castellana,Elisa Montiu González,Graciano García Pardo,Francesc Feliu Villaró,Josep Rebull Fatsini,Marie France Domènech Spaneda,Marta Conde Galí,Anna Oller Pérez-Hita,Lydia Martín,Ana Lerida,Sebastiano Biondo,Emilio Jiménez Martínez,Nieves Sopena Galindo,Ignasi Camps Ausàs,Carmen Ferrer,Luis Salas,Rafael Pérez Vidal,Dolors Mas Rubio,Irene García de la Red,Mª Angels Iruela Castillo,Eva Palau I Gil,José Antonio Martínez,M Blanca Torralbo Navarro,Maria López,Carol Porta,Alex Smithson Amat,Guillen Vidal Escudero,José Carlos de la Fuente Redondo,Montse Rovira Espés,Arantxa Mera Fidalgo,Luis Escudero Almazán,Monserrat Ortega Raya,Mª Carmen Álvarez Moya,Vicens Diaz-Brito,Laura Grau Palafox,Yésika Angulo Gómez,Anna Besolí Codina,Carme Autet Ricard,Carlota Hidalgo López,Elisabeth Lerma-Chippirraz,Demelza Maldonado López,David Blancas,Esther Moreno Rubio,Roser Ferrer I Aguilera,Simona Iftimie,Antoni Castro-Salomó,Rosa Laplace Enguídanos,Maria Carmen Sabidó Serra,Núria Bosch Ros,Virginia Pomar Solchaga,Laura Lázaro Garcia,Angeles Boleko Ribas,Jordi Palacín Luque,Alexandra Lucía Moise,Mª Carmen Fernández Palomares,Santiago Barba Sopeña,Eduardo Sáez Huertas,Sara Burges Estada,Josep María Tricas Leris,Eva Redon Ruiz,Montse Brugués,Susana Otero Aced,Maria Cuscó Esteve,Francisco José Vargas-Machuca,Mª de Gracia García Ramírez,Ana Maria Ciscar Bellés,Elena Vidal Díez,Mariló Marimón Morón,Marisol Martínez Sáez,Josep Farguell,Mireia Saballs,Montserrat Vaqué Franco,Leonor Invernón Garcia,Meritxell Guillemat Marrugat,Ana Coloma Conde
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/bjsopen/zrae080
2024-07-02
BJS Open
Abstract:Background: There is controversy regarding the maximum number of elements that can be included in a surgical site infection prevention bundle. In addition, it is unclear whether a bundle of this type can be implemented at a multicentre level. Methods: A pragmatic, multicentre cohort study was designed to analyse surgical site infection rates in elective colorectal surgery after the sequential implementation of two preventive bundle protocols. Secondary outcomes were to determine compliance with individual measures and to establish their effectiveness, duration of stay, microbiology and 30-day mortality rate. Results: A total of 32 205 patients were included. A 50% reduction in surgical site infection was achieved after the implementation of two sequential sets of bundles: from 18.16% in the Baseline group to 10.03% with Bundle-1 and 8.19% with Bundle-2. Bundle-2 reduced superficial-surgical site infection (OR 0.74 (95% c.i. 0.58 to 0.95); P = 0.018) and deep-surgical site infection (OR 0.66 (95% c.i. 0.46 to 0.93); P = 0.018) but not organ/space-surgical site infection (OR 0.88 (95% c.i. 0.74 to 1.06); P = 0.172). Compliance increased after the addition of four measures to Bundle-2. In the multivariable analysis, for organ/space-surgical site infection, laparoscopy, oral antibiotic prophylaxis and mechanical bowel preparation were protective factors in colonic procedures, while no protective factors were found in rectal surgery. Duration of stay fell significantly over time, from 7 in the Baseline group to 6 and 5 days for Bundle-1 and Bundle-2 respectively (P < 0.001). The mortality rate fell from 1.4% in the Baseline group to 0.59% and 0.6% for Bundle-1 and Bundle-2 respectively (P < 0.001). There was an increase in Gram-positive bacteria and yeast isolation, and reduction in Gram-negative bacteria and anaerobes in organ/space-surgical site infection. Conclusions: The addition of measures to create a final 10-measure protocol had a cumulative protective effect on reducing surgical site infection. However, organ/space-surgical site infection did not benefit from the addition. No protective measures were found for organ/space-surgical site infection in rectal surgery. Compliance with preventive measures increased from Bundle-1 to Bundle-2.