Abstract:In many scenarios, complete and incomplete information coexist. For this reason, the knowledge representation and database communities have long shown interest in simultaneously supporting the closed- and the open-world views when reasoning about logic theories. Here we consider the setting of querying possibly incomplete data using logic theories, formalized as the evaluation of an ontology-mediated query (OMQ) that pairs a query with a theory, sometimes called an ontology, expressing background knowledge. This can be further enriched by specifying a set of closed predicates from the theory that are to be interpreted under the closed-world assumption, while the rest are interpreted with the open-world view. In this way we can retrieve more precise answers to queries by leveraging the partial completeness of the data. The central goal of this paper is to understand the relative expressiveness of OMQ languages in which the ontology is written in the expressive Description Logic (DL) ALCHOI and includes a set of closed predicates. We consider a restricted class of conjunctive queries. Our main result is to show that every query in this non-monotonic query language can be translated in polynomial time into Datalog with negation under the stable model semantics. To overcome the challenge that Datalog has no direct means to express the existential quantification present in ALCHOI, we define a two-player game that characterizes the satisfaction of the ontology, and design a Datalog query that can decide the existence of a winning strategy for the game. If there are no closed predicates, that is in the case of querying a plain ALCHOI knowledge base, our translation yields a positive disjunctive Datalog program of polynomial size. To the best of our knowledge, unlike previous translations for related fragments with expressive (non-Horn) DLs, these are the first polynomial time translations.

Variants into minimal logic of the Kuroda negative translation

On Various Negative Translations

Kolmogorov and Kuroda Translations Into Basic Predicate Logic

A Kuroda-style j-translation

Kuroda's Translation for Higher-Order Logic

Normalisation for Negative Free Logics without and with Definite Descriptions

Kuroda's Translation for the $λΠ$-Calculus Modulo Theory and Dedukti

On the Various Translations between Classical, Intuitionistic and Linear Logic

Polarizing Double Negation Translations

Bijective Faithful Translations among Default Logics

Propositional calculus with multiple negations

Proof-graphs for Minimal Implicational Logic

Log Minimal Models According to Shokurov

Logic programming with default, weak and strict negations

Variations on the Kripke Trick

On logic of paradox

Models of transfinite provability logic

A Note on Tableaux of Logic of Paradox.

Polynomial Rewritings from Expressive Description Logics with Closed Predicates to Variants of Datalog

Minimal Predicates, Fixed-Points, and Definability

Sub-sub-intuitionistic logic