Stop the Bleed-Wait for the Ambulance or Get in the Car and Drive? A Post Hoc Analysis of an EAST Multicenter Trial
John T Simpson,Kristen D Nordham,Danielle Tatum,Elliot R Haut,Ayman Ali,Zoe Maher,Amy J Goldberg,Leah C Tatebe,Grace Chang,Sharven Taghavi,Shariq Raza,Eman Toraih,Michelle Mendiola Plá,Scott Ninokawa,Christofer Anderson,Patrick Maluso,Jane Keating,Sigrid Burruss,Matthew Reeves,Lauren E Craugh,David V Shatz,Apoorva Bhupathi,M Chance Spalding,Aimee LaRiccia,Emily Bird,Matthew R Noorbakhsh,James Babowice,Marsha C Nelson,Lewis E Jacobson,Jamie Williams,Michael Vella,Kate Dellonte,Thomas Z Hayward 3rd,Emma Holler,Mark J Lieser,John D Berne,Dalier R Mederos,Reza Askari,Barbara Okafor,Eric Etchill,Raymond Fang,Samantha L Roche,Laura Whittenburg,Andrew C Bernard,James M Haan MD,Kelly L Lightwine,Scott H Norwood,Jason Murry,Mark A Gamber,Matthew M Carrick,Nikolay Bugaev,Antony Tatar
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/00031348241265135
2024-09-30
Abstract:Background: The Stop the Bleed campaign gives bystanders an active role in prehospital hemorrhage control. Whether extending bystanders' role to private vehicle transport (PVT) for urban penetrating trauma improves survival is unknown, but past research has found benefit to police and PVT. We hypothesized that for penetrating trauma in an urban environment, where prehospital procedures have been proven harmful, PVT improves outcomes compared to any EMS or advanced life support (ALS) transport.Methods: Post-hoc analysis of an EAST multicenter trial was performed on adult patients with penetrating torso/proximal extremity trauma at 25 urban trauma centers from 5/2019-5/2020. Patients were allocated to PVT and any EMS or ALS transport using nearest neighbor propensity score matching. Univariate analyses included Wilcoxon signed rank or McNemar's Test and logistic regression.Results: Of 1999 penetrating trauma patients in urban settings, 397 (19.9%) had PVT, 1433 (71.7%) ALS transport, and 169 (8.5%) basic life support (BLS) transport. Propensity matching yielded 778 patients, distributed equally into balanced groups. PVT patients were primarily male (90.5%), Black (71.2%), and sustained gunshot wounds (68.9%). ALS transport had significantly higher ED mortality (3.9% vs 1.9%, P = 0.03). There was no difference in in-hospital mortality rate, hospital LOS, or complications for all EMS or ALS only transport patients.Conclusion: Compared to PVT, ALS, which provides more prehospital procedures than BLS, provided no survival benefit for penetrating trauma patients in urban settings. Bystander education incorporating PVT for early arrival of penetrating trauma patients in urban settings to definitive care merits further investigation.