Abstract:Background: In recent years, a range of novel smartphone-derived data streams about human mobility have become available on a near-real-time basis. These data have been used, for example, to perform traffic forecasting and epidemic modeling. During the COVID-19 pandemic in particular, human travel behavior has been considered a key component of epidemiological modeling to provide more reliable estimates about the volumes of the pandemic's importation and transmission routes, or to identify hot spots. However, nearly universally in the literature, the representativeness of these data, how they relate to the underlying real-world human mobility, has been overlooked. This disconnect between data and reality is especially relevant in the case of socially disadvantaged minorities. Objective: The objective of this study is to illustrate the nonrepresentativeness of data on human mobility and the impact of this nonrepresentativeness on modeling dynamics of the epidemic. This study systematically evaluates how real-world travel flows differ from census-based estimations, especially in the case of socially disadvantaged minorities, such as older adults and women, and further measures biases introduced by this difference in epidemiological studies. Methods: To understand the demographic composition of population movements, a nationwide mobility data set from 318 million mobile phone users in China from January 1 to February 29, 2020, was curated. Specifically, we quantified the disparity in the population composition between actual migrations and resident composition according to census data, and shows how this nonrepresentativeness impacts epidemiological modeling by constructing an age-structured SEIR (Susceptible-Exposed-Infected- Recovered) model of COVID-19 transmission. Results: We found a significant difference in the demographic composition between those who travel and the overall population. In the population flows, 59% (n=20,067,526) of travelers are young and 36% (n=12,210,565) of them are middle-aged (P<.001), which is completely different from the overall adult population composition of China (where 36% of individuals are young and 40% of them are middle-aged). This difference would introduce a striking bias in epidemiological studies: the estimation of maximum daily infections differs nearly 3 times, and the peak time has a large gap of 46 days. Conclusions: The difference between actual migrations and resident composition strongly impacts outcomes of epidemiological forecasts, which typically assume that flows represent underlying demographics. Our findings imply that it is necessary to measure and quantify the inherent biases related to nonrepresentativeness for accurate epidemiological surveillance and forecasting.

Mobility-driven synthetic contact matrices: a scalable solution for real-time pandemic response modeling

Estimating social contact rates for the COVID-19 pandemic using Google mobility and pre-pandemic contact surveys

Little Italy: An Agent-Based Approach to the Estimation of Contact Patterns- Fitting Predicted Matrices to Serological Data

Morocco’s population contact matrices: A crowd dynamics-based approach using aggregated literature data

Generalized contact matrices for epidemic modeling

Estimating household contact matrices structure from easily collectable metadata

Leveraging Human Mobility Data for Efficient Parameter Estimation in Epidemic Models of COVID-19

Policy and Newly Confirmed Cases Universally Shape the Human Mobility During COVID-19

Preserving friendships in school contacts: an algorithm to construct synthetic temporal networks for epidemic modelling

Quantifying age-specific household contacts in Aotearoa New Zealand for infectious disease modelling

Apparent structural changes in contact patterns during COVID-19 were driven by survey design and long-term demographic trends

Individual social contact data and population mobility data as early markers of SARS-CoV-2 transmission dynamics during the first wave in Germany—an analysis based on the COVIMOD study

Estimating fine age structure and time trends in human contact patterns from coarse contact data: the Bayesian rate consistency model

Real-time tracking and prediction of COVID-19 infection using digital proxies of population mobility and mixing

Improving the use of social contact studies in epidemic modelling

A Mixed-Method Approach to Determining Contact Matrices in the Cox's Bazar Refugee Settlement

Mobility network models of COVID-19 explain inequities and inform reopening

A big-data driven approach to analyzing and modeling human mobility trend under non-pharmaceutical interventions during COVID-19 pandemic

Nonrepresentativeness of Human Mobility Data and its Impact on Modeling Dynamics of the COVID-19 Pandemic: Systematic Evaluation