A compendium of bona fide reference markers for genuine plant-derived extracellular vesicles and their degree of phylogenetic conservation

Miriam Morales Rodriguez de Lope,Ibone Rubio Sanchez-Pajares,Estela Herranz,Cristina Maria Lopez-Vazquez,Ainara Gonzalez-Moro,Alan Rivera-Tenorio,Carlos Gonzalez-Sanz,Soledad Sacristan,Eduardo Chicano-Galvez,Fernando de la Cuesta

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.11.21.624247

2024-12-04

Abstract:Although the field of plant-derived EVs (PDEVs) is experimenting an exponential growth, rigorous characterization complying with MISEV guidelines has not been yet implemented due to the lack of bona fide reference markers. In this work, we have paved the way for the standardization of PDEV markers, providing the most profound proteomic data so far from apoplastic washing fluid-derived EVs, a sample enriched in genuine extracellular vesicles from plant tissue, as opposed to methods involving tissue disruption; of two reference plant species: Arabidopsis thaliana (Arath-EVs) and Brassica oleracea (Braol-EVs). Additionally, we have conducted an exhaustive analysis of the proteomic data available so far from genuine EVs from any plant species, evaluating current potential markers, together with those found in our proteomic analyses. Our results provide evidence supporting the potential use of the following families as PDEV markers: fasciclin-like arabinogalactan proteins (FLAs), patellins, germin-like proteins, aquaporins, heat shock 70 proteins, 14-3-3 like proteins, Rab proteins, and vacuolar-type ATPase complex subunits. Next, we analyzed the presence of orthologues and their degree of conservation throughout plant taxa, as well as in 2 reference species from the animal kingdom: human and mouse. Their degree of conservation was compared with that of current EV markers used in animal-derived EVs: CD63, CD81 and CD9. Among the protein families with potential to be used as PDEV markers, 3 were found to be plant-specific: FLAs, patellins and germin-like proteins. Among these, fasciclin-like arabinogalactan (FLA) proteins, in particular FLA1, FLA2 and FLA8, were recurrently identified in EVs from different plant sources showing great abundance and thus arise as a novel family of plant-specific GPI-anchored PDEV markers. Furthermore, FLAs hold promise as ideal PDEV markers since they have orthologues across the different plant subdivisions and display a similar phylogenetic distribution in plants to that of currently used markers in animals.

Molecular Biology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is the lack of standardized markers for plant - derived extracellular vesicles (PDEVs). Specifically, although research on plant - derived extracellular vesicles (PDEVs) is growing rapidly, there are currently no strict characterization methods that meet the MISEV guidelines formulated by the International Society for Extracellular Vesicles (ISEV), mainly due to the lack of truly reliable reference markers. To address this issue, the author has carried out the following work:

1. **In - depth proteomic analysis**: The author performed the most profound proteomic analysis on PDEVs extracted from the apoplast washing fluid (AWF) of two reference plant species - Arabidopsis thaliana and Brassica oleracea. These samples are rich in genuine extracellular vesicles from plant tissues, rather than samples obtained by tissue disruption methods.

2. **Comprehensive analysis of existing data**: The author also conducted an exhaustive analysis of the currently available proteomic data on genuine plant extracellular vesicles, evaluated the current potential markers, and verified them in combination with the results of their own proteomic analysis.

3. **Marker selection and verification**: Based on the above analysis, the author provided evidence to support the use of the following protein families as PDEVs markers: fasciclin - like arabinogalactan proteins (FLAs), patellins, germin - like proteins, aquaporins, heat shock 70 proteins, 14 - 3 - 3 - like proteins, Rab proteins and vacuolar - type ATPase complex subunits.

4. **Conservatism analysis**: The author further analyzed the homologues of these candidate markers in the plant kingdom and their degree of conservation, and compared them with the conservation degrees of the commonly used markers CD63, CD81 and CD9 for animal - derived extracellular vesicles. Among them, FLAs, patellins and germin - like proteins were found to be plant - specific markers. In particular, FLA1, FLA2 and FLA8 repeatedly appear in EVs from different plant sources, showing high abundance, and are therefore considered as new plant - specific GPI - anchored PDEVs markers.

Through these studies, the author aims to provide more stringent characterization criteria for plant - derived extracellular vesicles and promote the standardization process in this field.