Modelling the prebiotic origins of regulation & agency in evolving protocell ecologies

Ben Shirt-Ediss,Arian Ferrero-Fernandez,Daniele De Martino,Leonardo Bich,Alvaro Moreno,Kepa Ruiz-Mirazo
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.11.20.624505
2024-11-22
Abstract:How did natural systems develop the first mechanisms of regulation and what for? How could they turn into adaptive agents in a minimal (though deeply meaningful) biological sense? A novel simulation platform, "Araudia", has been implemented to address these questions, which are deeply interrelated, in a prebiotic scenario where metabolically diverse protocells are allowed to modify their dynamic behaviour in response to changes in their boundary conditions (e.g., nutrient concentrations in the medium) and/or in the activity of other protocells, including cross-feeding relationships. We extend consumer-resource models (CRMs) to a stochastic evolutionary framework in which novelty appears bottom-up (i.e., from small changes at the individual protocell level), and a short-term memory may also come forth and spread in the population, to demonstrate that simple adaptive/learning processes can have relevant effects at somatic times (i.e., within the lifetime of single protocells). Our interest in exploring the interplay between metabolic- physiological aspects and ecological-evolutionary ones derives from the fact that it provides a complex causal domain, where various spatial and temporal scales intermingle, and where both the actual and the potential (pathways/behaviours) must be considered. It is in such a complex domain where the appearance of regulation acquires full significance, as an effective means to navigate phenotypic spaces that become too big for unguided exploration, given the large number of possible functionalities (or functional states) accessible to each proto-cellular agent. The results obtained for several minimalist cases below show that, despite the non-trivial combination of --both endogenous and exogenous-- factors involved in the constitution of regulatory mechanisms, these are bound to play a critical role in the survival of infra- biological systems, especially under rapidly changing environmental conditions that longer-term adaptive mechanisms would not be able to cope with.
Biology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The core problems that this paper attempts to solve are: In the pre - life - origin environment, how did natural systems develop the initial regulatory mechanisms? And how did these mechanisms transform these systems into adaptive agents? Specifically, the paper explores in the protocell ecosystem how these simple protocells regulate their dynamic behaviors to respond to environmental changes (such as changes in nutrient concentrations in the medium) and the influence of other protocell activities, especially cross - feeding relationships. By implementing a new simulation platform "Araudia", the author studies these problems within an evolutionary framework. This framework allows novelty to be generated bottom - up from small changes at the individual protocell level and may form and spread short - term memory, thus demonstrating that simple adaptation/learning processes can have significant effects within the lifespan of a single protocell. The paper simulates different minimal protocell ecosystems, with particular attention to those protocells that can spontaneously evolve regulatory networks similar to the "lac - operon". Such networks can quickly and flexibly switch the nutrient preferences of the host protocells to match the most abundant nutrients in the environment. This ability of "nutrient - preference switching" is regarded as a primary agent property, which helps to explore pre - life - origin regulatory mechanisms and their influence on protocell behavior and adaptability under non - equilibrium and well - stirred conditions.