Unveiling the Hidden Feast: translating molecular detection into predation rate. An example on biological control by generalist predators in agricultural fields.

Abel Louis MASSON,Kevan Rastello,Ambre Sacco-Martret de Preville,Yann Tricault,Sylvain Poggi,Elsa Canard,Marie-Pierre Etienne,Manuel Plantegenest

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.11.18.624133

2024-11-20

Abstract:Very few processes are as decisive as predation in shaping the structure and dynamics of ecological communities. For most predator species, the number of prey items killed by a predator in a day (predation rate) remains impossible to assess because direct observations are scarce or impossible to acquire. To fill this gap, we propose here a Hierarchical Bayesian Model that integrates data on the molecular detection of prey in predators (e.g. PCR results), on individuals captured in the field on the one hand, and on individuals fed in the laboratory, on the other, in a novel mechanistic framework. By explicitly combining the processes of predation and digestion, model fit provides an estimate of the slope and intercept of the digestion curve, and an estimate of the number of prey consumed by a predator in a day. In a case study targeting 25 carabid beetle species and 5 types of prey in agricultural fields (winter wheat), we use our model to estimate predation rates at species and community scales and demonstrate its advantages for studies on biocontrol and beyond.

Biology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: how to accurately estimate the predation rate of predators in the natural environment (i.e., the number of prey that predators prey on per day). Since direct observation of predation events is usually difficult to achieve, especially in complex and difficult - to - observe ecosystems, such as small predatory insects (e.g., tiger beetles) in farmland, a new method needs to be developed to indirectly estimate the predation rate.

Specifically, the author proposes a **Hierarchical Bayesian Model (HBM)**, which combines molecular detection data (such as PCR results) of predators captured in the laboratory and in the field to infer the predation rate. By integrating the two processes of predation and digestion, the model can provide more accurate estimates of the predation rate and can be applied to biological control research and other ecological fields.

### Main problems:
1. **Limitations of direct observation**: The predation rates of most predators are difficult to obtain through direct observation because these species are often difficult to observe or their behaviors are disturbed.
2. **Deficiencies of existing methods**: Existing methods, such as functional response experiments or simple ratio correction based on molecular detection, have limitations and cannot fully consider complex natural environmental factors (such as the presence of multiple prey, environmental changes, etc.).
3. **Need for data integration**: A method that can utilize both laboratory and field data simultaneously is required to more comprehensively understand predation dynamics.

### Solutions:
- **Hierarchical Bayesian Model**: This model provides an estimate of the predation rate by combining molecular detection data from the laboratory and the field, as well as modeling the predation and digestion processes.
- **Application examples**: The paper shows the estimation of the predation rates of 25 species of tiger beetles preying on 5 species of prey (including pests, decomposers, and natural enemies) in French wheat fields by this model, and discusses its application potential in biological control.

Through this method, researchers can more accurately quantify the predation behavior of predators in the natural environment, thereby providing a scientific basis for ecological management and biological control.