Abstract:To understand psychological data, it is crucial to examine the structure and dimensions of variables. In this study, we examined alternative estimation algorithms to the conventional GLASSO-based exploratory graph analysis (EGA) in network psychometric models to assess the dimensionality structure of the data. The study applied Bayesian conjugate or Jeffreys' priors to estimate the graphical structure and then used the Louvain community detection algorithm to partition and identify groups of nodes, which allowed the detection of the multi- and unidimensional factor structures. Monte Carlo simulations suggested that the two alternative Bayesian estimation algorithms had comparable or better performance when compared with the GLASSO-based EGA and conventional parallel analysis (PA). When estimating the multidimensional factor structure, the analytically based method (i.e., EGA.analytical) showed the best balance between accuracy and mean biased/absolute errors, with the highest accuracy tied with EGA but with the smallest errors. The sampling-based approach (EGA.sampling) yielded higher accuracy and smaller errors than PA; lower accuracy but also lower errors than EGA. Techniques from the two algorithms had more stable performance than EGA and PA across different data conditions. When estimating the unidimensional structure, the PA technique performed the best, followed closely by EGA, and then EGA.analytical and EGA.sampling. Furthermore, the study explored four full Bayesian techniques to assess dimensionality in network psychometrics. The results demonstrated superior performance when using Bayesian hypothesis testing or deriving posterior samples of graph structures under small sample sizes. The study recommends using the EGA.analytical technique as an alternative tool for assessing dimensionality and advocates for the usefulness of the EGA.sampling method as a valuable alternate technique. The findings also indicated encouraging results for extending the regularization-based network modeling EGA method to the Bayesian framework and discussed future directions in this line of work. The study illustrated the practical application of the techniques to two empirical examples in R.

The problem of unmeasured variables in animal social network analysis: can edge-based multilevel models provide a reliable solution?

Analysis of sparse animal social networks

A causal framework for the drivers of animal social network structure

Robust Bayesian analysis of animal networks subject to biases in sampling intensity and censoring

Latent Network Models to Account for Noisy, Multiply-Reported Social Network Data

Joint mixed-effects models for causal inference in clustered network-based observational studies

Multilevel Longitudinal Analysis of Social Networks

Incorporating uncertainty into the study of animal social networks

Inferring the mesoscale structure of layered, edge-valued and time-varying networks

A Bayesian multilevel model for populations of networks using exponential-family random graphs

Why understanding multiplex social network structuring processes will help us better understand the evolution of human behavior

Modelling animal social networks: New solutions and future directions

A stochastic block model approach for the analysis of multilevel networks: An application to the sociology of organizations

Multiresolution network models

Social Networks with Unobserved Links

A framework to evaluate whether to pool or separate behaviors in a multilayer network

Exploring Estimation Procedures for Reducing Dimensionality in Psychological Network Modeling

Estimating psychopathological networks: be careful what you wish for

Ignoring measurement errors in social networks

Optimal Nonparametric Inference on Network Effects with Dependent Edges

Sifting out communities in large sparse networks