Sensitivity to climate change is widespread across zoonotic diseases

Artur Trebski,Lewis Gourlay,Rory Gibb,Natalie Imirzian,David W Redding

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.11.18.24317483

2024-11-18

Abstract:Climate change is expected to exacerbate infectious diseases, yet the climate sensitivity of zoonotic diseases (driven by spillover from animal reservoirs) is markedly understudied compared to vector-borne and water-borne infections. To address this gap, we conducted a global systematic review and quantitative synthesis to identify relationships between climatic indicators (temperature, precipitation, humidity) and zoonotic disease risk metrics worldwide. We identified 185 studies from 55 countries, describing 547 measures across 51 diseases, with most studies testing linear (n=166) rather than nonlinear (n=23) relationships. We found evidence of climate sensitivity across diverse zoonotic diseases (significant non-zero relationships in 64.3% of temperature effects, 49.8% of precipitation effects, and 48.9% of humidity effects), but with broad variation in direction and strength. Positive effects of temperature and rainfall on disease risk were more common than negative effects (39.1% vs. 25.2% and 30.5% vs. 19.2% of all records, respectively). These studies were predominantly located in areas expected to have substantial increases in annual mean temperature (>1.5oC in 93% of studies) and rainfall (>25 mm in 46% of studies) by 2041-2070. Notably, the most consistent relationship was between temperature and vector-borne zoonoses (50% of Positive effects, mean Hedge's g = 0.31). Overall, our analyses provide evidence that climate sensitivity is common across zoonoses, likely leading to substantial yet complex effects of future climate change on zoonotic burden. Finally, we highlight the need for future studies to use biologically appropriate models, rigorous space-time controls, consider causal perspectives and address taxonomic and geographic biases to allow a robust consensus of climate-risk relationships to emerge.

Epidemiology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand the impact of climate change on zoonotic diseases. Specifically, the research aims to fill a crucial gap in the existing literature: although there have been many studies on the impact of climate change on vector - borne diseases (such as mosquito - borne diseases), there is a relatively insufficient study on the climate sensitivity of zoonotic diseases directly transmitted from animal hosts to humans.

### Specific objectives of the study include:
1. **Identify which regions and zoonotic diseases are over - or underestimated in climate - sensitivity studies**: Through systematic review and quantitative synthesis, determine which diseases and regions have received sufficient attention in existing studies and which have been neglected.
2. **Determine the patterns of climate sensitivity**: Analyze whether there are consistent patterns of climate sensitivity among different types of diseases, regions, vectors, and hosts.
3. **Evaluate the appropriateness of research methods and indicators**: Examine whether existing studies have used appropriate methods to detect the relationship between climate and disease risk.
4. **Evaluate the differences in climate sensitivity of different transmission routes**: Compare the responses of vector - borne and non - vector - borne diseases to climate change.

### Main findings:
- **Temperature is the most consistent climatic factor**: Especially in vector - borne zoonotic diseases, an increase in temperature is usually associated with an increase in disease risk.
- **The influence of precipitation and humidity is more complex**: The impact of these factors on disease risk varies by disease type and region, and there is large variability.
- **Future climate change may exacerbate the risk of zoonotic diseases**: Many study sites are located in areas where a significant increase in temperature is expected in the future, which may further increase the risk of disease transmission.

### Future research needs:
- **Standardized and interdisciplinary research methods**: More consistent and rigorous methods need to be adopted, especially considering non - linear relationships and controlling for common epidemiological biases.
- **More diverse disease types and regional coverage**: There are obvious classification and geographical biases in current research, and a more comprehensive coverage of various zoonotic diseases and their occurrence regions is required.
- **In - depth exploration of biological mechanisms**: Understand how climate change affects disease transmission by changing the physiological responses of hosts and vectors.

In conclusion, this study emphasizes the extensive impact of climate change on zoonotic diseases and points out the limitations in existing research and the direction for future improvement.