Music education reduces emotional symptoms in children: A quasi-experimental study in the Guri Program in Brazil

Graziela Bortz,Beatriz Ilari,Nayana Di Giuseppe Germano,Andrea Parolin Jackowski,Hugo Cogo-Moreira,Patrícia Silva Lúcio

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.11.12.24317159

2024-11-12

Abstract:The transferability of music education to cognitive and social skills has been explored recently, but its causal effects remain debatable. This quasi-experimental study aimed to examine the impact of a music education program (Guri) on aspects attention, working memory and socioemotional skills in children from underserved communities of São Paulo, Brazil. The music group (n = 38, 5-9 years) was recruited from 10 centers (polos) distributed across the metropolitan area of São Paulo and the control group (n = 67) consisted of aged-matched children who attended public schools surrounding the polos. The ABEP SES questionnaire and the Raven test were used as control variables, the SDQ questionnaire, the Digit-span subtest from WISC-IV, the PARB-Q questionnaire, and the BPA test were used as subject variables. A significant effect of the intervention in emotional symptoms in the music group as opposed to controls was found (F(1,89) = 4.562, p = 0.035, h2 = 0.049), indicating benefits for the music group. Children whose mothers had low levels of education benefited with gains between 0.70 and 0.95 standard deviations in both groups for divided attention, indicating a significant interaction with maternal education.

Psychiatry and Clinical Psychology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem this paper attempts to address is whether music education can reduce emotional symptoms in children from impoverished areas of São Paulo, Brazil, and improve their attention, working memory, and socio-emotional skills.

Specifically, the researchers explored the impact of the "Guri" music education program on these children through a quasi-experimental design. The main objectives of the study include:

1. **Reduction of emotional symptoms**: Assess whether music education can significantly reduce children's emotional symptoms.
2. **Enhancement of cognitive skills**: Examine the impact of music education on children's attention (especially distractibility), working memory, and other cognitive aspects.
3. **Improvement of socio-emotional skills**: Analyze whether music education can improve children's socio-emotional skills, such as social abilities and emotional regulation.

The background section of the study mentions that although previous research suggests that music education may have positive effects on cognitive and social skills, its causal effects remain controversial. Therefore, this study aims to further verify the actual effects of music education on a specific group through a concrete experimental design.