Abstract:Background Physician diagnoses of abusive head trauma (AHT) have been criticized for circular reasoning and over-reliance on a "triad" of findings. Absent a gold standard, analyses that apply restrictive reference standards for AHT and non-AHT could serve to confirm or refute these criticisms. Objectives To compare clinical presentations and injuries in patients with witnessed/admitted AHT vs. witnessed non-AHT, and with witnessed/admitted AHT vs. physician diagnosed AHT not witnessed/admitted. To measure the triad's AHT test performance in patients with witnessed/admitted AHT vs. witnessed non-AHT. Participants and setting Acutely head injured patients <3 years hospitalized for intensive care across 18 sites between 2010 and 2021. Methods Secondary analyses of existing, combined, cross-sectional datasets. Probability values and odds ratios were used to identify and characterize differences. Test performance measures included sensitivity, specificity, and predictive values. Results Compared to patients with witnessed non-AHT ( n = 100), patients with witnessed/admitted AHT ( n = 58) presented more frequently with respiratory compromise (OR 2.94, 95% CI: 1.50–5.75); prolonged encephalopathy (OR 5.23, 95% CI: 2.51–10.89); torso, ear, or neck bruising (OR 11.87, 95% CI: 4.48–31.48); bilateral subdural hemorrhages (OR 8.21, 95% CI: 3.94–17.13); diffuse brain hypoxia, ischemia, or swelling (OR 6.51, 95% CI: 3.06–13.02); and dense, extensive retinal hemorrhages (OR 7.59, 95% CI: 2.85–20.25). All differences were statistically significant ( p ≤ .001). No significant differences were observed in patients with witnessed/admitted AHT (n = 58) vs. patients diagnosed with AHT not witnessed/admitted ( n = 438). The triad demonstrated AHT specificity and positive predictive value ≥0.96. Conclusions The observed differences in patients with witnessed/admitted AHT vs. witnessed non-AHT substantiate prior reports. The complete absence of differences in patients with witnessed/admitted AHT vs. physician diagnosed AHT not witnessed/admitted supports an impression that physicians apply diagnostic reasoning informed by knowledge of previously reported injury patterns. Concern for abuse is justified in patients who present with "the triad."

High G-Forces in Unintentionally Improper Infant Handling: Implications for Shaken Baby Syndrome Diagnosis

Update on injury mechanisms in abusive head trauma - shaken baby syndrome

[Brain injury following child maltreatment syndrome in newborns and young children. Shaken baby syndrome]

Outcome after severe non-accidental head injury

Animal models of pediatric abusive head trauma

Characteristics and associations of ocular and non-ocular manifestations of shaken baby syndrome

Shaking up our approach: The need for characterization and optimization of preclinical models of infant abusive head trauma

Cerebral Hemorrhage Caused by Shaking Adult Syndrome? Evidence from Biomechanical Analysis Using 3D Motion Capture and Finite Element Models

Diagnosis of Abusive Head Trauma : Neurosurgical Perspective

Injury biomechanics for aiding in the diagnosis of abusive head trauma

Retinal hemorrhage variation in inertial versus contact head injuries

An analysis of physicians' diagnostic reasoning regarding pediatric abusive head trauma

Characteristics of shaken baby syndrome in a regional Japanese children’s hospital

Non-accidental fatal head injury in small children--a clinico-pathological correlation

Patterns of accidental craniocerebral injury occurring in early childhood

Influence of the benign enlargement of the subarachnoid space on the bridging veins strain during a shaking event: a finite element study

Development of a Child Head Analytical Dynamic Model Considering Cranial Nonuniform Thickness and Curvature - Applying to Children Aged 0-1 Years Old

The Swedish Agency for health technology-report about traumatic shaking: much ado about nothing?

Cerebrospinal Fluid Interaction with Cerebral Cortex during Pediatric Abusive Head Trauma

Abusive head trauma: The body of the iceberg – A population-based survey on prevalence and perpetrators

Mechanical properties and anthropometry of the human infant head