Abstract:Tree species of Eurasian broadleaved forest possess two divergent trait syndromes with contrasting patterns of resource allocation adapted to different selection environments: short‐stature basal resprouters that divert resources to a bud bank adapted to frequent and severe disturbances such as fire and herbivory, and tall trees that delay reproduction by investing in rapid height growth to escape shading. Drawing on theory developed in savanna ecosystems, we propose a conceptual framework showing that the possession of contrasting trait syndromes is essential for the persistence of broadleaved trees in an open ecosystem that burns. Consistent with this hypothesis, trees of modern Eurasian broadleaved forest bear a suite of traits that are adaptive to surface and crown‐fire regimes. We contend that limited opportunities in grassland restricts recruitment to disturbance‐free refugia, and en masse establishment creates a wooded environment where shade limits the growth of light‐demanding savanna plants. Rapid height growth, which involves investment in structural support and the switch from a multi‐stemmed to a monopodial growth form, is adaptive in this shaded environment. Although clustering reduces surface fuel loads, these establishment nuclei are vulnerable to high‐intensity crown fires. The lethal effects of canopy fire are avoided by seasonal leaf shedding, and aerial resprouting enhances rapid post‐fire recovery of photosynthetic capacity. While these woody formations satisfy the structural definition of forest, their constituents are clearly derived from savanna. Contrasting trait syndromes thus represent the shift from consumer to resource regulation in savanna ecosystems. Consistent with global trends, the diversification of most contemporary broadleaved taxa coincided with the spread of grasslands, a surge in fire activity and a decline in wooded ecosystems in the late Miocene–Pliocene. Recognition that Eurasian broadleaved forest has savanna origins and persists as an alternative state with adjacent grassy ecosystems has far‐reaching management implications in accordance with functional rather than structural criteria. Shade is a severe constraint to the regeneration and growth of both woody and herbaceous growth forms in consumer‐regulated ecosystems. However, these ecosystems are highly resilient to disturbance, an essential process that maintains diversity especially among the species‐rich herbaceous component that is vulnerable to shading when consumer behaviour is altered.

Self-pruning in tree crowns is influenced by functional strategies and neighborhood interactions

Tree Morphology Responds to Neighbourhood Competition and Slope in Species-Rich Forests of Subtropical China

Asymmetric Pruning Reveals How Organ Connectivity Alters the Functional Balance Between Leaves and Roots of Chinese Fir.

Different Performing Trees Manifest Varied Scaling Relationships at Individual and Branch Levels

Predicting vegetation type through physiological and environmental interactions with leaf traits: evergreen and deciduous forests in an earth system modeling framework

Light mediates the relationship between community diversity and trait plasticity in functionally and phylogenetically diverse tree mixtures

Functional Diversity of Neighbours Mediates Sap Flow Density and Radial Growth of Focal Trees, but in Different Ways Between Evergreen and Deciduous Broadleaved Species

The role of tree crown on the performance of trees at individual and community levels: whole-phenotypic context matters

Partial Shading of Lateral Branches Affects Growth, and Foliage Nitrogen- and Water-Use Efficiencies in the Conifer Cunninghamia Lanceolata Growing in a Warm Monsoon Climate.

Functionally diverse tree stands reduce herbaceous diversity and productivity via canopy packing

Plastic Responses in Tree Architecture to Different Light Intensity Habitats: A Case of Chinese Cork Oak

Early overyielding in a mixed deciduous forest is driven by both above- and below ground species-specific acclimation

Growth, Biomass Allocation and Photosynthetic Responses Are Related to Intensity of Root Severance and Soil Moisture Conditions in the Plantation Treecunninghamia Lanceolata

Tree crowns grow into self-similar shapes controlled by gravity and light sensing

Nutrient foraging strategies are associated with productivity and population growth in forest shrubs

Patterns of Branch Growth and Death in Crowns of Sakhalin Spruce, Picea Glehnii (F. Schmidt) Mast

Size-symmetric Competition in a Shade-Tolerant Invasive Plant

Functional Traits Mediate Seedling Survival Response to Climate in a Temperate Forest

Leaf trait variation within individuals mediates the relationship between tree species richness and productivity

Interspecific coordination and intraspecific plasticity of fine root traits in North American temperate tree species

Solutions to fire and shade: resprouting, growing tall and the origin of Eurasian temperate broadleaved forest