Provision of medical Same Day Emergency Care services within the UK: analysis from the Society for Acute Medicine Benchmarking Audit

Catherine Atkin,Madeleine Perrett,Mark Holland,Tim Cooksley,Thomas Knight,Ragit Varia,Chris Subbe,Daniel Lasserson,Elizabeth Sapey
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.10.13.24315407
2024-10-14
Abstract:Aim: To evaluate current provision of medical Same Day Emergency Care (SDEC) services within the UK, and current utilisation of these pathways in the assessment of unplanned medical attendances. Design: Survey data was used from the Society for Acute Medicine Benchmarking Audit (SAMBA), including anonymised patient-level data collected annually using a day of care survey Setting: Hospitals accepting unplanned medical attendances within the UK, 2019-2023. Participants: 34,948 unplanned and 4,342 planned attendances, across 188 hospital sites Results: 29.8% of unplanned medical attendances received their initial medical assessment within SDEC services, with the proportion increasing over time. 82.4% of patients assessed in SDEC services were discharged without overnight admission. Assessment in SDEC services was less likely in male patients, patients with frailty, and older adults (all p<0.005). Selected operational standards for SDEC delivery were met in 64-91% of hospitals. Most hospitals (82%) accepted referrals from emergency department triage and 63% accepted referral directly from the paramedic team. 38% of hospitals did not use a recognised selection criteria to identify suitable patients for SDEC and only 8% used a criteria designed to identify patients suitable for discharge. Overall, 34.7% of medical attendances discharged without overnight admission received their medical assessment in locations other than SDEC. Conclusions: Medical SDEC provides assessment for one third of patients seen through acute medicine services. Although the proportion of patients assessed within SDEC is increasing, further innovation and improvements are needed to ensure appropriate patients access this service.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to evaluate the current situation of "Same Day Emergency Care (SDEC)" in the UK healthcare system and its application in handling unplanned medical visits. Specifically, the research aims to: 1. **Describe the current structure of SDEC services**: By analyzing the data of the Society for Acute Medicine Benchmarking Audit (SAMBA), understand the organizational forms, operation processes, and resource allocations of SDEC services in UK hospitals. 2. **Evaluate the usage of SDEC pathways**: Analyze the application of SDEC pathways in handling planned and unplanned medical visits, especially which patient factors are related to management through SDEC services. 3. **Identify areas for improvement**: Although SDEC services have been widely adopted, there are significant differences in the way they are provided among different hospitals, and there is a lack of sufficient evaluation of their impact on patient flow, acute service pathways, or patient care. Therefore, the research also aims to identify opportunities for further innovation and improvement to ensure that appropriate patients can access this service. ### Key Findings - **Increased utilization rate of SDEC services**: 29.8% of unplanned medical visits received an initial medical assessment in SDEC services, and this proportion has gradually increased over time. - **Most patients do not need overnight hospitalization**: Among the patients evaluated in SDEC services, 82.4% ultimately did not need overnight hospitalization. - **Low utilization rate in specific patient groups**: Male patients, frail patients, and elderly patients have a lower utilization rate in SDEC services (all p < 0.005). - **Compliance with operational standards**: Most hospitals (64 - 91%) have met the selected SDEC delivery standards. - **Referral sources**: Most hospitals (82%) accept referrals from emergency department triage, and 63% of hospitals accept direct referrals from emergency teams. ### Conclusions SDEC services provide assessment for approximately one - third of acute medical service patients. Although its utilization rate is increasing, further innovation and improvement are still needed to ensure that more appropriate patients can benefit from this service. In addition, the research also emphasizes the importance of promoting standardized operating procedures among different regions and hospitals to improve service quality and efficiency. ### Research Significance This research is the largest - scale evaluation of SDEC services to date, showing the growth trend of SDEC service use nationwide. However, the participation rate is low in the other three UK countries outside England, which may limit the universality of the results.