Abstract:Background: Interactions between peptide and MHC class II (pMHC-II) are crucial for T-cell recognition and immune responses, as MHC-II molecules present peptide fragments to T cells, enabling the distinction between self and non-self antigens. Accurately predicting the pMHC-II binding core is particularly important because it provides insights into pMHC-II interactions and T-cell receptor engagement. Given the high polymorphism and peptide-binding promiscuity of MHC-II molecules, computational prediction methods are essential for understanding pMHC-II interactions. While sequence-based methods are widely used, recent advances in AlphaFold-based structure prediction have opened new possibilities for improving pMHC-II binding core predictions. Results: We benchmarked four recent pMHC-II prediction methods with a focus on binding core prediction: two sequence-based methods, NetMHCIIpan and DeepMHCII, and two AlphaFold-based structure prediction methods, AlphaFold2 fine-tuned for peptide interactions (AF2-FT) and AlphaFold3 (AF3). The AlphaFold-based methods showed strong performance in predicting positive binders, with AF3 achieving the highest positive recall (0.86) and AF2-FT performing similarly (0.81). However, both methods frequently misclassified unbound peptides as binders. NetMHCIIpan excelled at identifying non-binders, achieving the highest negative recall (0.93), but had lower positive recall (0.44). In contrast, DeepMHCII demonstrated moderate performance without any notable strength. Consensus approaches combining AlphaFold-based methods for binder identification with filtering using NetMHCIIpan improved overall prediction precision (0.94 and 0.87 for known and unknown binding status, respectively). Conclusions: This study highlights the complementary strengths of AlphaFold-based and sequence-based methods for predicting pMHC-II binding core regions. AlphaFold-based methods excel in predicting positive binders, while NetMHCIIpan is highly effective at identifying non-binders. Future research should focus on improving the prediction of unbound peptides for AlphaFold-based models. Since NetMHCIIpan's binding core predictive ability is already high, future efforts should concentrate on enhancing its binding prediction to further improve overall accuracy.

Pan-Prediction of MHC-II Restricted Epitopes Across Species via an Alphafold-based Quantification Scheme

Predicting MHC-I ligands across alleles and species: How far can we go?

Pan-Specific Mhc Class I Predictors: A Benchmark of Hla Class I Pan-Specific Prediction Methods

Benchmarking Sequence-Based and AlphaFold-Based Methods for pMHC-II Binding Core Prediction: Distinct Strengths and Consensus Approaches

Peptide binding predictions for HLA DR, DP and DQ molecules

BiodMHC: an Online Server for the Prediction of MHC Class II-peptide Binding Affinity.

MHCII-peptide presentation: an assessment of the state-of-the-art prediction methods

Toward more accurate pan-specific MHC-peptide binding prediction: a review of current methods and tools.

Deep Learning-Enhanced MHC-II Presentation Prediction and Peptidome Deconvolution

Using a novel structure/function approach to select diverse swine major histocompatibility complex 1 alleles to predict epitopes for vaccine development

MetaMHCpan, A Meta Approach for Pan-Specific MHC Peptide Binding Prediction.

PSSMHCpan: a novel PSSM-based software for predicting class I peptide-HLA binding affinity

ACME: Pan-specific peptide-MHC class I binding prediction through attention-based deep neural networks

Improving Prediction of MHC Class I Binding Peptides with Additional Binding Data

MHCRoBERTa: pan-specific peptide-MHC class I binding prediction through transfer learning with label-agnostic protein sequences

Machine learning application to predict binding affinity between peptide containing non-canonical amino acids and HLA0201

MetaMHC: a meta approach to predict peptides binding to MHC molecules.

Identifying B-cell epitopes using AlphaFold2 predicted structures and pretrained language model

NetMHCpan-4.1 and NetMHCIIpan-4.0: improved predictions of MHC antigen presentation by concurrent motif deconvolution and integration of MS MHC eluted ligand data

Improving MHC Binding Peptide Prediction by Incorporating Binding Data of Auxiliary MHC Molecules

PredMHC: An Effective Predictor of Major Histocompatibility Complex Using Mixed Features