Infections are not alike: the effects of covariation between individual susceptibility and transmissibility on epidemic dynamics

Jeremy D Harris,Esther Gallmeier,Jonathan Dushoff,Stephen J Beckett,Joshua S Weitz

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.10.11.24315334

2024-10-12

Abstract:Individual-level variation in susceptibility to infection and transmissibility of infection can affect population-level dynamics in epidemic outbreaks. Prior work has incorporated independent variation in susceptibility or transmissibility of individuals into epidemic compartmental models. Here, we develop and assess a mathematical framework that includes covariation in susceptibility and transmissibility. We show that uncorrelated variation in susceptibility and transmissibility leads to an effective transmissibility distribution that has a constant coefficient of variation such that the epidemic dynamics match those with variation in susceptibility alone, providing a baseline for comparison across different correlation structures. Increasing the correlation between susceptibility and transmissibility increases both the speed and strength of the outbreak – and is indicative of outbreaks which might be strongly structured by contact rate variation. In contrast, negative correlations between susceptibility and transmissibility lead to overall weaker outbreaks – with the caveat that the strength of effective transmission increases over time. In either case, correlations can shift the transmissibility distribution, thereby modifying the speed of the epidemic as the susceptible population is depleted. Overall, this work demonstrates how (often unaccounted) covariation in susceptibility and transmission can shape the course of outbreaks and final outbreak sizes.

Epidemiology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the issue of how the covariance between individual susceptibility and infectivity affects epidemic dynamics during infectious disease outbreaks. Specifically, the researchers developed a mathematical framework that incorporates changes in individual-level susceptibility and infectivity into traditional epidemiological models (such as the SIR model) to explore the impact of these changes on the speed, intensity, and ultimate scale of the epidemic spread.

The main contributions of the paper are:
1. **Introduction of a Covariance Model**: The researchers proposed a new model that includes the covariance of susceptibility and infectivity and demonstrated how this covariance affects the basic reproduction number (\(R_0\)) and the characteristics of epidemic spread.
2. **Analysis of Different Correlations**: The study found that positive correlation leads to a faster and more intense outbreak, while negative correlation weakens the spread of the epidemic, although the effective transmission rate increases over time.
3. **Validation of Simplified Models**: By comparing the results of a fully discrete model with a simplified model, it was verified that in the absence of correlation, the simplified model can approximate the actual epidemic dynamics well.

In summary, this paper aims to reveal how the interaction between individual susceptibility and infectivity shapes the development of an epidemic and provides a new perspective for understanding epidemic dynamics.