Neural dynamics of spontaneous memory recall and future thinking in the continuous flow of thoughts

Haowen Su,Xian Li,Savannah Born,Christopher J. Honey,Janice Chen,Hongmi Lee

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.10.02.616300

2024-10-02

Abstract:The human brain constantly recalls past experiences and anticipates future events, generating a continuous flow of thoughts. However, the neural mechanisms underlying the natural transitions and trajectories of thoughts during spontaneous memory recall and future thinking remain underexplored. To address this gap, we conducted a functional magnetic resonance imaging study using a think-aloud paradigm, where participants verbalize their uninterrupted stream of thoughts during rest. We found that transitions between thoughts, particularly those involving significant shifts in semantic content, activate the brain's default and control networks. These neural responses to internally generated thought boundaries produce activation patterns resembling those triggered by external event boundaries. Moreover, interactions within and between these networks shape the overall semantic structure of thought trajectories: stronger functional connectivity within the medial temporal subsystem of the default network predicts greater variability in thoughts, while stronger connectivity between the control and core default networks is associated with reduced variability. Together, our findings highlight how the default and control networks guide the dynamic transitions and structure of naturally arising memory and future thinking.

Neuroscience

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the neural mechanism of how the human brain dynamically transitions between spontaneous memory recall and future thinking and its trajectory in a natural state. Specifically, the research aims to explore the following questions:

1. **Organizing Principles**: What are the main organizing principles that guide the transition from one thought to the next?
2. **Neural Characteristics**: What are the neural characteristics of these thought transitions?
3. **Network Interaction**: How do brain networks interact to generate changing or stable thought trajectories?

To answer these questions, researchers used the "think - aloud paradigm" combined with functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI), allowing participants to freely describe their thought streams during the rest period. By analyzing the transition probabilities and semantic similarities between thoughts, the researchers found:

- **Semantic Association**: Transitions between thoughts are mainly guided by semantic associations, although shared cognitive processes (i.e., thought categories) also play a certain role.
- **Boundary Activation**: Strong thought boundaries (especially semantically discontinuous boundaries) activate the default network and adjacent control network regions, producing a distributed activation pattern similar to that triggered by external event boundaries.
- **Network Interaction**: The interaction between the default network and the control network shapes the overall semantic structure of the thought trajectory. Specifically, stronger functional connectivity within the default network subsystem (including the hippocampus) predicts greater semantic variability, while stronger connectivity between the default network and the control network is associated with lower variability.

These findings emphasize the central role of the default network and the control network in organizing the dynamic transitions and structures of spontaneous memory and future thinking in a natural state.