Abstract:Abstract Background The reindeer (or caribou, Rangifer tarandus L.) has a natural range extending over much of Eurasia’s and North America’s arctic, alpine and boreal zones, yet its impact on vegetation is still unclear. This lack of a common understanding hampers both the management of wild and semi-domesticated reindeer populations and the preservation of biodiversity. To achieve a common platform, we have undertaken a systematic review of published studies that compare vegetation at sites with different reindeer densities. Besides biodiversity, we focused on effects on major plant growth forms. Methods Searches for literature were made using online publication databases, search engines, specialist websites and bibliographies of literature reviews. Search terms were developed in English, Finnish, Norwegian, Russian and Swedish. Identified articles were screened for relevance based on titles, abstracts and full text using inclusion criteria set out in an a priori protocol. Relevant articles were then subject to critical appraisal of susceptibility to bias. Data on outcomes such as abundance, biomass, cover and species richness of vegetation were extracted together with metadata on site properties and other potential effect modifiers. Results Our searches identified more than 6,000 articles. After screening for relevance, 100 of them remained. Critical appraisal excluded 60 articles, leaving 40 articles with 41 independent studies. Almost two thirds of these studies had been conducted in Fennoscandia. Meta-analysis could be made of data from 31 of the studies. Overall, effects of reindeer on species richness of vascular plants depended on temperature, ranging from negative at low temperature to positive at high temperature. Effects on forbs, graminoids, woody species, and bryophytes were weak or non-significant, whereas the effect on lichens was negative. However, many individual studies showed clear positive or negative effects, but the available information was insufficient to explain this context dependence. Conclusions We see two pressing matters emerging from our study. First, there is a lack of research with which to build a circumpolar understanding of grazing effects, which calls for more studies using a common protocol to quantify reindeer impacts. Secondly, the highly context-dependent outcomes suggest that research and management have to consider local conditions. For instance, predictions of what a management decision would mean for the effects of reindeer on vegetation will have to take the variation of vegetation types and dominant growth forms, productivity, and grazing history into account. Policy and management have to go hand-in-hand with research in individual cases if the dynamics between plants, animals, and humans are to be sufficiently understood.

Impact assessment and indigenous rights: Cumulative impact assessment of forestry on winter pastures in Mudusjävri reindeer herding co-operative in Finland

Between the local and the global? - reindeer herders' perspectives on land use challenges and conflicts in the Sámi homeland, Finland

Health impact assessment of a mining project in Swedish Sápmi: lessons learned

Indicators of Sustainable Forestry: Methodological Approaches for Impact Assessments across Swedish Forestry

What are the impacts of reindeer/caribou (Rangifer tarandus L.) on arctic and alpine vegetation? A systematic review

Land use synergies and conflicts identification in the framework of compatibility analyses and spatial assessment of ecological, socio-cultural and economic values

Maintenance of flying squirrel habitat and timber harvest: a site-specific spatial model in forest planning calculations

Impact Evaluation of a Payments for Ecosystem Services Program on Vegetation Quantity and Quality Restoration in Inner Mongolia.

Climate change and reindeer herding – A bioeconomic model on the impact of climate change on harvesting profits for Saami reindeer herders in Norway and Sweden

A modelling approach to inform regional cumulative effects assessment in northern Ontario

Modelling Alternative Economic Incentive Schemes for Semi-Natural Grassland Conservation in Estonia

Predicting snow structures relevant to reindeer husbandry

Climate change, cultural continuity and ecological grief: Insights from the Sámi Homeland

Experimental evidence of the long‐term effects of reindeer on Arctic vegetation greenness and species richness at a larger landscape scale

The Impacts of the Eco-Environmental Policy on Grassland Degradation and Livestock Production in Inner Mongolia, China: an Empirical Analysis Based on the Simultaneous Equation Model

Reconstructing Food Ways: Role of Skolt Sami Cultural Revitalization Programs in Local Plant Use

Combining scientific and local knowledge improves evaluating future scenarios of forest ecosystem services

Research, part of a Special Feature on A Framework for Analyzing, Comparing, and Diagnosing Social-Ecological Systems Does Pastoralists' Participation in the Management of National Parks in Northern Norway Contribute to Adaptive Governance?

Cost-efficient forest management for safeguarding Siberian flying squirrel (Pteromys volans) habitats in Central Finland

Environmental sustainability of Finnish pork production: life cycle assessment of climate change and water scarcity impacts

The Sámi cultural landscape as the scene of collective memory and identity — challenges in preserving